A remarkable event in the history of the Santa Clarita Valley took place last week.
A federal agency once hell-bent on authorizing mining in Soledad Canyon made a complete about-face and terminated the contracts tied to that project.
Without a doubt this was the biggest development for the greatest issue facing the city of Santa Clarita since the proposed Elsmere Canyon mega-dump.
The decision by the BLM to cancel mining contracts held by Cemex in Soledad Canyon was greeted with almost unanimous cheers from local residents.
After all, the city has been fighting the Cemex mine for 20 years. For the last several years Cemex and Santa Clarita have been engaged in a media and public relations truce intended to help the sides work together cooperatively to find a solution to make Cemex whole yet avoid or reduce mining in Soledad Canyon.
I firmly believe that both the city and Cemex entered into that truce with the best intentions. The Bureau of Land Management and the politicians and government employees who run the country’s largest and most profitable government agency were not held to that gentleman’s agreement, however.
As a result, the BLM unilaterally — and according to Cemex without provocation — canceled the Soledad Canyon mining permits under the justification that Cemex failed to get the mine started.
In essence, the BLM used Cemex’s magnanimous gesture of a truce with the city to claim that the global mining and construction firm was “nonresponsive” to demands allegedly made by the BLM that Cemex mine or get off the pot.
Cemex believed, and the record shows, that the only reason the firm held off on the acquisition of final permits and the transfer of mining equipment to the site was to avoid provocation that violated the truce with the city.
When I refer to the record showing this to be the case, I am referring not only to the numerous media accounts of the truce and process of finding a legislative solution, but also to the BLM’s own account, which it helpfully documented in the decision letter.
While on one hand claiming Cemex was unresponsive to the BLM demand that mining commence, the federal agency admits it was repeatedly reminded that Cemex was engaged in the truce with the city and therefore could not engage in the demanded activities.
Cemex further stipulated a number of times that it believed it was operating in such a fashion as to not have started the clock on the period of time that the company had to begin mining.
We do not know Cemex’s side of the record of evidence, but I’d guess the mining firm would not have continued under this assumption if it had not been validated in writing by the BLM.
I am going to hold off on speaking to the judicial correctness of the BLM’s decision to use Cemex’s own desire to find a solution to mining as a means with which to rob it of its right to mine.
But it doesn’t take a business lawyer to see that a government bureaucracy that was once intent on mining in Soledad Canyon felt politically pressured to terminate those mining contracts by any means possible.
To cap off its sordid decision and perhaps in a vain attempt to intimidate Cemex against an appeal, the BLM claims that any attempt to assert that the mining contracts are still legitimate will result in a demand from the BLM for $17.4 million in fees due in lieu of the payments Cemex would have made on the sale of extracted aggregate.
In fact, the BLM does not even address future plans for the mining site in its letter to Cemex. This leaves all of us in a state of uncertainty until the appeal process and potential litigation is complete.
Regardless of how you may feel about mining in Soledad Canyon, we must not lose sight of the fact that the process the BLM has used here is very questionable.
The agreement Cemex entered into with the city was intended to produce “mutually acceptable solutions which may include federal legislation that, if successful, will result in a win-win for the city, the community, as well as for Cemex.”
Instead, the BLM came in and, with the tacit permission of the city, nullified the contracts and assessed a fine should Cemex decide to appeal the decision.
A government agency that can do this to one of the world’s largest mining firms can do a great deal more to regular citizens, small businesses and municipalities — things that won’t have the citizenry cheering.
Process does matter, and the process used to terminate the Cemex mine in Soledad Canyon was bad process and bad government.
Steve Petzold is a Saugus resident.
