This weekend, our family went to Santa Barbara and relaxed. We ate, shopped, and meandered.
It was fun hanging out with all the rich liberal white people whose collective guilt is assuaged by large donations to the DNC.
The greatest collection of BMWs and Mercedes (outside of Beverly Hills and Brentwood) has got to be downtown Santa Barbara on a Saturday night.
All of the wealthy local denizens of the hills come down to the watering holes on State Street to commiserate and complain about “that devil, George W. Bush.”
I thought about this as I was biking down Cabrillo Boulevard when I noticed a man behind me screaming “eagle! Eagle!”
I turned and saw a scruffy little man carrying large bags on his back and shoulders sauntering slowly toward the center of the city.
“Just another homeless person,” I callously thought. Not being a doctor, I could not ascertain if the man was mentally ill, but the incessant screaming of “eagle” was a small clue as to what was happening here.
But then something happened. I began noticing many homeless people in the downtown Santa Barbara area. The old lady who made camp on the bus bench next to our resort.
The scruffy pair of men “camped” under a palm tree on the beach. The young lady sitting at the corner had a sign reading “hard times.”
In fact, as I rode, I noticed a homeless person every 40 yards or so. Sometimes small groups, sometimes singles. But always a constant undercurrent of homeless humanity.
I began to examine my own thinking about homelessness and how I had changed over the years. In younger days, I used to comment that homelessness was a choice and, to some extent, this is still true.
However, as I have gotten older and a little bit wiser, I have observed another cause that seems to be a more significant factor: mental illness.
Almost every person I observed during my ride was exhibiting some form of societal oddness: screaming, talking to invisible friends, rocking, poor hygiene.
This got me thinking. What is the link between mental illness and homelessness?
In 2007, the National Alliance for the Homeless estimated that 34 percent of homeless folks have some form of schizophrenia or manic-depressive disorder.
In 2009, the National Coalition for the Homeless (quoted from the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration) estimated that 20 percent to 25 percent of the homeless have some form of severe mental illness.
In 2012, the National Alliance to End Homelessness estimated that 40 percent of all homeless have a “serious mental illness.”
I wonder. If you remove the folks who are “transitionally homeless” (people who find themselves homeless but rapidly find a permanent place to live), these numbers could be far higher.
Maybe there is a permanent underclass of homeless who are mentally ill.
So what has rich and prosperous Santa Barbara done to address the problem?
A great deal, it appears, all to no avail.
Randy Alcorn of Santa Barbara’s Noozhawk wrote in 2012 that “all the attempted solutions — the new shelters, the community generosity, the multitude of tax- and charity-supported agencies and institutions — have not abated the problem.”
In fact, the homeless population in Santa Barbara seems to have grown.
Could it be that the root cause of a great deal of homelessness is not simply lack of resources but mental illness? Is that why all of the philanthropy of wealthy Santa Barbara has failed to impact the problem?
Recently, a program was started in San Francisco to simply provide housing to homeless people. The rationale was that it actually saved local municipalities in the form of civic services to give the homeless a home.
A valiant effort, but if the root cause is mental illness, the program turns into a cynical do-gooder approach that is a waste of taxpayer resources.
What about gun violence? A common thread in most of these incidents is not just guns but mental illness. Our society appears to be breeding mentally ill people at an alarming rate.
Take away the guns and people will still be killing people. Guns are not the root cause.
I am beginning to wonder if our approach to so many societal problems is simply missing the mark. A person is homeless so we give that person a cot for the night and a warm meal, blaming his or her lack of resources for the problems.
A person goes on a shooting rampage and we blame guns and the NRA.
Maybe it’s time we begin to look more closely at mental health services and how improvements in this area may improve other problem areas.
It’s clear our current approach is not working. Just take a bike ride with me in Santa Barbara.
Steve Lunetta is a resident of Santa Clarita. He can be reached at [email protected].
