Population, geography and — possibly — where current incumbents live are all factors that can be looked at as the Santa Clarita Community College District ponders how to split itself into voting areas.
Each of those is listed among criteria that can come into play as the district, which oversees College of the Canyons, splits itself into five different voting areas tied to seats on the district’s board.
One topic of discussion at Wednesday’s board meeting — when board members approved the shift to a voting-area election system, in which voters within a specific area will elect a board member to represent that area — was the idea that board incumbency could play a role in how the district’s new voting areas are drawn.
As an exhibit included in the board agenda puts it, “The boundaries of the trustee areas may avoid the ‘pairing’ of incumbents in the same trustee area, insofar as this does not conflict with the Constitution and laws of the state of California and the United States.”
Wendy Brill-Wynkoop, president of the College of the Canyons Faculty Association, questioned whether that criteria could be found in state or federal law.
“These new trustee districts do not belong to the trustees themselves or the chancellor or the school,” she said at Wednesday’s meeting. “They are districts for the community.”
Mary Dowell, of the district’s law firm Liebert Cassidy Whitmore, told the board that seeking to avoid drawing voting areas in which multiple incumbents reside is a legal, and even common, consideration.
For instance, the voting-area map for in the William S. Hart Union High School District, approved last May by county overseers, has each of its five current board members in different voting areas. Hart district’s boundaries are largely similar to those of the community college district.
Dowell said the major consideration in drawing voting-area boundaries is to ensure the population in each is as close to equal as possible.
“We need to avoid packing one area with too many voters and having too few in another,” she said.
The 2010 Census showed the community college district had 267,152 residents, meaning each “ideal” voting area would have about 53,430 people, Dowell said.
Voting areas are re-examined when new Census data becomes available to take into account population changes, Dowell added.
Other factors that will help guide the drawing of the map include keeping voting areas as compact, cohesive and contiguous as possible — and avoiding gerrymandering, according to an agenda document. The voting areas must “not result in a denial or abridgement of the right of any citizen to vote on account of race or color,” it said.
Topography and geography can also be considered, the document said.
Santa Clarita Valley residents have been able to vote for any seat on COC’s board, but a 2013 California Voting Rights Act lawsuit that alleged the system prevented Latino voters from electing candidates of their choice prompted the district to look at new election options.
To settle that lawsuit, COC agreed to move to cumulative voting — a system in which it would be possible to vote multiple times for the same candidate.
COC reserved the right to move to voting areas, however, and opted to do so after the California Secretary of State announced the office would not be able to certify the voting machines that would be used in a cumulative voting election.
661-287-5525
On Twitter @LukeMMoney
