The Newhall Ranch housing development proposed for the Santa Clarita Valley won a legal victory this week when a state appellate court upheld the environmental review and approval of the Mission Village portion of the project.
The Second District Court of Appeal on Tuesday unanimously upheld a 2014 Los Angeles Superior Court ruling that affirmed the environmental impact report for Mission Village, which is one phase of the long-planned and much-debated Newhall Ranch development that would add some 21,000 new homes to the Santa Clarita Valley’s northwest side.
“The county’s exhaustive environmental review was affirmed by the Court of Appeal to have been completed diligently and properly,” said Emile Haddad, president and CEO of Five Point Communities, the development manager for project planner Newhall Land Development Inc.
“We are thankful for the county’s efforts and look forward to implementing the plans for Mission Village.” Haddad said in a statement issued late Tuesday. “We also appreciate the court’s diligence in carefully deciding each of the legal issues presented.”
A representative from one of the plaintiffs in the case said Wednesday the decision was not a surprise and the matter could eventually make its way to the California Supreme Court.
“It was not unexpected, first of all,” said Lynne Plambeck, president of the Santa Clarita Organization for Planning and the Environment, or SCOPE. “This division of the Second Appellate Court has not ruled for a conservation group in 20 years.”
Proposed for long-held Newhall Land Development property south of Highway 126, Mission Village would be a mixed-use development including 4,055 homes, 1.56 million square feet of commercial space and public amenities such as an elementary school, a fire station, a public library and parks, according to Newhall Land.
The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors approved the EIR and other land-use permits for Mission Village in 2012, according to Newhall Land.
But a number of groups sued, alleging issues with the EIR.
Those groups alleged the EIR did not properly examine issues such as greenhouse gas emissions and the development’s potential impacts on natural habitat in the area.
The appellate court, though, rejected those contentions.
Plambeck said she thinks it’s “patently absurd” for the court to uphold findings that a 21,000-home development project would not have a significant impact on greenhouse gas emissions.
“I think if you go to any man on the street and you say, ‘Is there going to be a big impact on greenhouse gases from all those cars commuting back and forth?’ the answer is going to be yes,” she said Wednesday. “So I don’t think you need to be a rocket scientist to see there’s going to be an issue there.”
Tuesday’s ruling is just the latest round in the years-long legal fight over the Newhall Ranch project.
A lawsuit challenging permits issued by the California Department of Fish and Wildlife for the development went before the California Supreme Court in early September.
A different lawsuit opposing the developer’s plans for Landmark Village — another portion of the Newhall Ranch project — has also been appealed to the state high court.
“We will be petitioning that they hear this one too because it’s related,” Plambeck said, referring to the Mission Village case.
The state Supreme Court is expected to issue a ruling on the Fish and Wildlife case within the next 60 days or so, said John Buse, senior counsel for the Center for Biological Diversity.
661-287-5525
On Twitter @LukeMMoney
