A series of California Voting Rights Act lawsuits, either filed or threatened, have drastically altered the election landscape in the Santa Clarita Valley.
But while voters came face-to-face with the effects of those lawsuits for the first time in Tuesday’s elections, the taxpayers governed by them have had to shell out more than $2 million in combined costs as a result, officials said Friday.
The city of Santa Clarita, Sulphur Springs School District and Santa Clarita Community College District were each hit with California Voting Rights Act lawsuits in quick succession in the summer of 2013.
Each lawsuit contained largely the same allegation: that the use of at-large voting, in which voters had a say in electing every school board or City Council member, prevented Latino residents from being able to elect candidates of their choice.
Though each of those lawsuits was eventually settled, the city and school districts racked up sizable bills as a result.
The total financial impact of the lawsuit to Sulphur Springs is approximately $197,000, according to district Superintendent Catherine Kawaguchi.
As part of the settlement, Sulphur Springs agreed to move away from at-large voting to a new voting-area election system.
The district was split into five different voting areas, each tied to a seat on the school board.
Residents within each voting area would be able to vote for one candidate to represent that area, but would not be able to vote for any other board members.
Sulphur Springs was supposed to hold its first voting-area election this week, but the election was canceled after no one signed up to run against the two board incumbents up for re-election.
The plaintiff in that suit, Rosemarie Sanchez-Fraser, was represented by two law firms in that case — the Malibu-based law firm Shenkman & Hughes and the R. Rex Parris Law Firm in Lancaster.
The same two firms represented Sanchez-Fraser and another local resident, Jim Soliz, in the lawsuit against the city of Santa Clarita.
“The city has spent about $650,000 in attorneys’ fees — including special counsel and experts — and will be required to pay $600,000 in settlement to the plaintiffs,” wrote City Attorney Joe Montes in an email Friday.
The same plaintiffs and law firms also filed the lawsuit against the community college district that oversees College of the Canyons.
As part of its agreement to settle the lawsuit, COC agreed to shell out about $850,000 in plaintiffs’ legal fees, said college spokesman Eric Harnish.
That is on top of any fees the college paid to its own attorneys, or the cost of hiring a demographer to draw voting-area maps for the college, he said Friday.
Both the city and COC also agreed to move their elections to November of even-numbered years.
COC’s election in November 2016 will be held using voting areas, while the City Council election will still be at-large.
The Saugus Union School District was also hit with a California Voting Rights Act lawsuit earlier this year.
The district is working toward a settlement, according to Superintendent Joan Lucid, but the terms of that are not yet known.
The Saugus district is also moving to voting-area elections and will hold its next election in November 2016.
Though the total costs of California Voting Rights Act lawsuits in the Santa Clarita Valley are expected to exceed $2 million, they pale in comparison to those seen in the neighboring city of Palmdale, which was also sued under the California Voting Rights Act.
After a lengthy legal battle, the Antelope Valley city agreed earlier this year to pay plaintiffs’ attorneys $4.5 million.
661-287-5525
On Twitter @LukeMMoney
