I am writing in response to a letter to the editor written by Jim Haley and published Nov. 7 in The Signal (“Social Security recipients need a COLA”).
It is sad that a disabled person is experiencing such a hard time financially when he reasonably expected that government would serve his needs.
He is one of the millions of people relying on Congressional promises that Congress is not going to be able to keep.
Unfortunately, older retired people pay a disproportionately high share of medical expenses. The inflation in the medical arena is rampant, so his cost of living is increasing at a rate significantly higher than that of the general public.
Social Security COLAs are based on the general rate of inflation, leaving Social Security recipients in a bind.
Unfortunately, those relying on Social Security as their principal means of support cannot reasonably expect to see any meaningful increases in their lifetime.
Making medical services more affordable would undoubtedly help Social Security recipients’ situation from getting worse.
Mr. Haley mentioned a couple of things in his letter that perhaps are misconceptions. First, I am unaware of a growing movement to expand Social Security. If anything, future benefits are likely to be cut as means testing and other proposals are enacted.
Mr. Haley intimated that the rich are not paying their fair share.
The system is based on taxing a percentage of wages, salaries and other types of personal services income. The ultra-rich generally receive the bulk of their income from investments, which is not subject to Social Security tax. Thus they receive no Social Security benefits.
The high-income wage earners pay significant amounts of Social Security tax and many ultimately will never receive benefits equal to what they paid in.
Perhaps a better way to equitably deal with the situation is to merge the Social Security fund with the general fund and replace the Social Security tax with an incremental income tax that is spread over a broader base, including investment income.
Unfortunately, I don’t see the immediate solution to this dilemma that Mr. Haley so urgently seeks.
