It’s depressing to see that the recent terror attacks on Paris have brought out a level of paranoia and xenophobia not seen here since 9/11.
And we know how well that panicked overreaction worked out: a $4 trillion pre-emptive war based on faulty intel, illegal wiretapping of Americans, employing torture and imprisoning captives without charges or evidence for years.
Whether it’s on social media or in the irresponsible statements of Republican presidential candidates, it’s clear we’re reaching another tipping point of mass hysteria.
Once again, we’re seeing rampant Islamophobia masquerading as safety concerns.
It was evident when Muslim “Clock Kid” Ahmed Mohamed was the target of such conspiracy-mongering and venom from the right that his family finally had to leave the country.
It was evident when Ben Carson said that Muslims should be disqualified from running for president.
And it’s reached an apex now that American conservatives want to turn away the innocent refugees displaced by the bloody Syrian civil war — a war that’s already resulted in more than 200,000 civilian dead.
Let’s walk through the syllogism at the heart of conservatives’ arguments:
The terrorists who attacked Paris were Muslim extremists.
Syrian refugees are mostly Muslim.
Therefore, all Syrian refugees are potential terrorists.
Therefore, all Syrian refugees must be barred from America.
Does that reasoning make sense to you? If so, congratulations: You just committed the Fallacy of Composition and flunked your logic exam.
It’s worth pointing out that all of the terrorist attacks in Paris were committed by French nationals. None of them were Syrian refugees or even posing as Syrian refugees.
Granted, this is little comfort if you’re reacting based on fear rather than facts.
What’s funny is that people who think it’s rational to turn away all Syrian refugees because there’s a slim chance a few bad guys might slip through are some of the same people who deride “anti-vaxxers” for refusing to vaccinate their kids because it might cause autism. Or the ones who mock the folks wary of G.M.O. foods because they might prove harmful down the line.
The common fallacy is the same: Because we can’t have 100 percent certainty of safety and there’s a negligible chance of danger, therefore it’s prudent to avoid the situation entirely.
If we followed this line of thinking to its absurd conclusion, it would be considered suicidal to ever drive because there’s a tiny chance we might die in a car accident.
Look, everyone agrees that in a post-9/11 world our safety and security demands that we should thoroughly vet all refugees to the best of our ability.
Where we disagree is that it’s reasonable to soil our Jockeys in fear that every Syrian or Iraqi refugee is a potential sleeper cell suicide bomber capable of unleashing chaos on the streets of America like some episode of “Homeland.”
Conservatives warn that if we let thousands of Syrian refugees into America, then we’re potentially opening the floodgates to a new wave of terrorist attacks.
Pay no attention to the fact that since 2001, America has admitted around 750,000 refugees and zero have been involved in domestic terrorism attacks.
And please ignore the nearly 20,000 Iraqi refugees accepted into the U.S. just last year.
In fact, there are already millions of Muslims who live and work in America. So if the problem is that we can’t trust them, well — that horse has already left the stable.
Beyond that, we already suffer terrorist attacks here; weekly, in fact. Since 2015 began, we’ve had 325 terrorist incidents — mass shootings, to be precise — on U.S. soil.
But since those terrorist incidents involve Americans rather than foreigners committing the mayhem, conservatives don’t count those.
Apparently, the mere threat of religiously inspired violence frightens Republicans far more than the reality of random acts of mass murder occurring weekly across the country.
It’s hard to believe this is really how conservatives want the world to view America. We’re a brave superpower eager to take a wrecking ball to huge swaths of the Middle East to defend innocent people from Muslim extremists.
Just don’t ask us to welcome those same innocent people as refugees, because we’re just too paralyzed with stark raving fear.
Not only does this undermine our moral authority and give the appearance of capitulating to the terrorists, but it validates the narrative of Muslim extremists hungry to recruit moderate Muslims by convincing them the West is only interested in bombing and occupying their lands and doesn’t really care about helping them.
It was Ronald Reagan who famously said, “We must not yield to the terrorist demands that invite more terrorism.”
But if we’re now going to let terrorists dictate our humanitarian efforts and our national security policies, and force us to apply a religious test to refugees, then we may as well call “uncle” in the War on Terror, because they’ve already won.
America is the greatest country on Earth, a shining beacon of hope in a dark world. It’s high time we started acting like it again and stopped surrendering to fear.
Charlie Vignola is a former college Republican turned liberal Democrat. He lives in Fair Oaks Ranch, works in the motion picture industry and loves his wife and kids.
