Editor’s note: Adds Newhall Land response.
Citing the effects of greenhouse gas emissions and insufficient protection for a tiny endangered fish, California’s highest court Monday tossed out the developer’s report concluding 21,000 planned homes in the Newhall Ranch project would not adversely affect the environment.
The California Supreme Court ruled Monday that Newhall Land Development Inc. failed to provide evidence in its Environmental Impact Report to prove its project was consistent with meeting state guidelines to control harmful greenhouse gas.
The court also concluded that measures calling for capture and relocation of the unarmored threespine stickleback — a species of fish protected by the California Department of Fish and Wildlife — amounted to illegal movement, or “take,” of the endangered indigenous fish.
The decision threatens to delay the project.
“We are reviewing the decision of the Supreme Court and will continue to consult and work with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife on appropriate next steps consistent with the court’s guidance,” Newhall Land spokesman Steve Churm said in written statement in response to the court decision.
“We remain committed to realizing the vision of Newhall Ranch and the significant benefits it promises for the economy and future of Los Angeles County,” he wrote.
Setback
John Buse, an attorney representing the Center for Biological Diversity, said the court decision Monday poses “significant problems for Newhall Land.”
“It’s not going to be easy for them to move forward,” said Buse, whose Center for Biological Diversity is one of the groups that sued over Newhall Ranch in 2011. “But if they want to move forward, they’re going to have to see about making some pretty profound changes on how they do things.”
Lawyers representing Newhall Land Development Inc., along with those representing environmental groups opposed to its plan to build 21,000 new homes northwest of Valencia, presented arguments to the Supreme Court in September.
Buse, one of two Center for Biological Diversity lawyers who argued the case in September, addressed the environmental harm, and the legality, of moving the unarmored threespine stickleback.
The other center lawyer argued the developer failed to prove how it could meet state guidelines on curbing greenhouse gas emissions.
“It’s one thing to protect and preserve the fish,” Buse told The Signal Monday. “It’s quite another thing to scoop them up and move them out of the way.
“Their attempt to move them out of the way (of the development) is improper under state law,” he said.
Lawsuits
In January 2011 environmentalists sued the California Department of Fish & Wildlife and Newhall Land alleging Newhall Ranch would destroy natural habitat for native plants and animals, among them the San Fernando Valley spineflower and the unarmored threespine stickleback.
On Oct. 15, 2012, Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Ann Jones — citing flaws in Newhall Land’s EIR — ruled in favor of the environmentalist groups’ challenge of the project.
In a pingpong round of court action, Newhall Land appealed the decision.
In February 2014, both sides presented their respective arguments before a panel of three Los Angeles appellate court judges.
Judges of the Second Appellate District Court announced a reversal in March 2014 of the Judge Jones decision made in favor of environmentalists.
That appellate court decision was appealed to the state Supreme Court.
The Newhall Ranch housing development — which has yet to break ground though it’s been planned for some 20 years — would be a master-planned community from the same firm that planned and developed Valencia.
After its projected 25- to 30-year construction period, it would include more than 20,000 residences west of Interstate 5.
Environmentalists say it would destroy natural habitat near the Santa Clara River.
Greenhouse gas
One of the many environmental arguments made in February 2014 was the effect of cars parked in the driveway of every one of the 21,000 Newhall Ranch homes — an impact Buse says would contribute to greenhouse gas emissions.
The 112-page court decision released by the appellate judges in 2014 dismissed that argument and upheld the findings of the project’s 5,828-page Environmental Impact Report prepared by the California Department of Fish and Wildlife.
On the specific issue of greenhouse gas, the court determined the environmentalists’ contentions had no merit.
Newhall Land officials argued that the Environmental Impact Report they prepared was sound and sensitive to the environment.
The first phase of Newhall Ranch was approved by Los Angeles County supervisors in February 2012 after exhaustive studies.
The project calls for developing 422 lots on about 295 acres. That would produce 270 single-family homes, 744 condominiums and 430 apartments, along with 16 commercial lots.
The phase 1 plan also calls for 119 lots for open space, plus at least one fire station, park and school.
661-287-5527
On Twitter @jamesarthurholt.com
