It is hard not to take personal offense at Congressman Steve Knight’s recent words in these pages (“Taking in refugees is dangerous,” Nov. 19 in The Signal). I am the child of Syrian immigrants and I grew up in Santa Clarita.
Rep. Knight, R-Palmdale, wrote that “no amount of vetting ... could possibly guarantee Syrian immigrants pose no substantial security threat,” so I am left wondering if he also looks upon me or my parents, who have lived in Santa Clarita for three decades, with a distrustful eye.
A public official should not engage in broad-brush racial generalizations. A public official should also be familiar with the communities he represents.
Rep. Knight may be surprised to learn that a thriving population of Syrian-Americans lives in his district in places like Valencia, Canyon Country, Acton, Lancaster, and Palmdale. They are not only voters, but neighbors.
They are students, shop owners, workers, and doctors. Like their neighbors, they work hard, they care for their families, and they are trying to contribute something to the community.
Substantial security threat, needless to say, is not how their neighbors see them.
Indeed, Rep. Knight’s attitude toward people from Syria does not reflect the Santa Clarita I knew.
The morning of Sept. 11, 2001, my father had just dropped me off at Hart High School for my first class of the day. He had to drive to work early, so I would usually arrive on campus shortly after 6 a.m. and wait for 7 a.m. classes to start. It was freshman year English.
That morning, before the bell rang, my teacher was listening to the radio, obviously distraught. I didn’t understand the news right away, and sometimes I still wonder if I ever will.
In the following days, my English teacher asked me to stay after class to speak privately. She wanted to know if anyone had teased me since the attacks. No, I said, nothing serious, just friends joking around.
It’s not a joke, she pressed, urging me to tell her or her husband, another teacher, if anyone ever harassed me. That’s never okay, she said. (I was fortunate enough never to need her help, but I have heard terrible bullying stories from others I’ve met over the years.)
Through her model behavior, my English teacher taught me a lesson that was deeply American (and deeply Christian — she and her husband are both people of faith, and he is a local pastor): You do not judge a person because of his faith, his race, or his national origin.
I hope Rep. Knight can take that lesson to heart.
The attacks in Paris raise many questions. They have provoked a range of emotions: shock, anger, grief, pain, empathy and, of course, fear. These emotions should stir us to action, yes — but thoughtful action.
Rep. Knight’s proposals, unfortunately, are not very thoughtful. The bill he voted for (H.R. 4038) does not improve the “vetting” of refugees, but rather creates a more bloated bureaucracy that is not capable of keeping us safe or helping deserving refugees escape violence.
Our country’s refugee application process is already amongst the most complex and thorough in the world, taking nearly two years to complete due to the number of agencies and background checks involved.
In fact, none of the Paris attackers were Syrian refugees — several actually held European passports, and Rep. Knight’s proposal would have done nothing to stop them from entering the United States.
When policies are based on racial stereotypes rather than real security needs, innocent people are bound to suffer. Rep Knight should consider the human impact of his proposal. He should perhaps meet his Syrian-American constituents.
They might explain to him that their friends and relatives overseas — the very refugees he maligns in his op-ed piece — want their families to be safe, too.
They are fleeing a brutal civil war. They are caught between the Assad dictatorship and a motley crew of terrorist groups that become more horrifying by the day. They want freedom, safety and a place for their children to grow. The last thing they want is to live in the despotic and inhospitable Gulf countries that neighbor them — and helped destroy their country.
Let us hope that Rep. Knight will listen to his constituents, re-evaluate his position, and return to Congress with better ideas. Because he has not only turned his back on Syrian refugees. He has also turned his back on American values and the lessons of history.
Yaman Salahi grew up in Santa Clarita. He is currently a civil rights lawyer in San Francisco.
