The California Supreme Court’s rejection of the Newhall Ranch environmental impact report after 20 years of preparation leaves some familiar with the project saying the blow may be harmful not only to the company that is developing the project, but to the local economy as well.
“Newhall Ranch is probably one of the most analyzed and reviewed projects in California history,” said Holly Schroeder, president and CEO for the Santa Clarita Valley Economic Development Corp. “To have it sent back after decades of scrutiny by dozens of government agencies shows that the process is clearly broken.”
Developer Newhall Land declined to comment as to what “impact the Supreme Court decision will have on either the future of residential/commercial development in California, or specifically the proposed Newhall Ranch,” said spokesman Steve Churm, chief communications officer with Five Point Communities.
Sitting on almost 12,000 acres along the Santa Clara River west of the city of Santa Clarita, Newhall Ranch proposes to build up to 20,885 dwelling units to house nearly 58,000 residents. The community would be built out incrementally over a number of years.
Even both justices writing pro and con opinions on sending back the environmental impact report admitted compliance with CEQA – the California Environmental Quality Act – will be a moving target, impossible to satisfy and a never-ending battle.
So how does Newhall Land stay afloat after a 20-year effort to build Newhall Ranch and following its tremendous success building its first master-planned community of Valencia?
The company
“I don’t think it’s the end. I think it probably means they’ll have to look at doing some things differently,” said Jim Backer, founder of JSB Development and a former executive with Newhall Land. “They’re definitely stopped right now, and they’ll have to figure something out.”
Backer points out, however, the enormous costs the company has had to bear over the years without ever getting a single dollar in return on the project.
Rulings like this could put a company out of business in California, he said.
“They’ve paid property taxes all this time” he said. “They’ve also had to pay their people, consultants and experts to review their plans, attorney fees and permits. To a certain extent, it’s all been for naught to date.”
The project has been put before review hearings for 20 years; the company has made design changes, drafted and re-drafted environmental impact reports – a virtual case study for the viability of large development projects in the state and how they should be analyzed.
“The EIR reports would probably fill a 200-square-foot office,” Backer said. “What does that say about private property owner rights or development of a community?”
One of the two objections the justices had to the Newhall Ranch environmental report was its failure to address the greenhouse gases that would be emitted by residents living in the outlying community.
But in his dissenting opinion, Justice Ming W. Chin noted, “CEQA does nothing to control California’s population growth. The 58,000 or so people the proposed project is intended to accommodate will not just go away. They will be living and working somewhere.”
In other words, those people will still be emitting greenhouse gases somewhere, he argues. And perhaps they will be emitting even more man-made gases by commuting further to reach their employers in the Santa Clarita Valley.
The economy
In many cases, local businesses’ employee bases commute into the Santa Clarita Valley from the Antelope and San Fernando valleys. In fewer cases, people are even commuting in from the west side of Los Angeles and Koreatown near downtown L.A.
Likewise, a majority of residents commute outside the area each day for higher-paying jobs.
In a 2008 report by the California Planning Roundtable, Santa Clarita was specifically cited as the one area in Southern California where “large numbers of residents get in their cars to commute to jobs in other cities.”
And that is a problem for Santa Clarita economically, said one source.
If the region does a good job of recruiting more companies to relocate to the Santa Clarita Valley, in turn providing residents with higher-paying jobs, there could be a future shortage of options to house a growing employee base here.
Build-out of Newhall Ranch would support a 3:1 jobs-to-housing balance, bringing thousands of permanent and construction-related jobs to the community, Schroeder said.
And beyond the tremendous positive economic impacts from construction activity, Newhall Ranch would provide an ongoing supply of housing, Schroeder said.
“Having a range of housing types for workers of all levels is important for recruiting employers to the SCV,” she said.
And so, to some degree, lack of future housing could delay economic development.
Glacial progress
Justice Ming wrote that “the harm is in delay,” saying litigation has already delayed implementing the EIR by some five years or so.
He predicted that kicking the EIR issues back to the lower court will only create more litigation.
“Given the glacial pace of litigation, this will easily take years,” Ming wrote. “Delay the project long enough and it has to meet new targets, and then perhaps new targets after that. All this is a recipe for paralysis.”
So how does the company survive the glacial movement?
Newhall Land still has a large amount of land with some farming and other means of income from its properties, Backer said. But it’s been very expensive to work through this process.
“Until then they will need some ‘patient capital’ (investors who are patient enough to wait out the process) to work with, to get through whatever is needed to get the project done,” Backer said.
