“And by that destiny to perform an act
Whereof what's past is prologue, what to come
In yours and my discharge.”
Antonio, in Shakespeare’s Tempest, urges Sebastian to murder his father, rationalizing that all that has happened is merely an introduction to what could be Sebastian’s future as the ruler of an empire.
This may resonate with the folks at Newhall Land and Farm (NLF) after they read the Supreme Court’s decision in the case concerning their proposed Newhall Ranch development.
Unfortunately for them, however, the prologue, which is the Supreme Court’s opinion, does not bode well for the project’s future.
For those few who are unaware of Newhall Ranch, it’s NLF’s vision of what 21,000 homes along the 126 freeway with 58,000 residents looks like. Approved by Los Angeles County twelve years ago, it’s been ping-ponging between courts, delaying its groundbreaking almost indefinitely.
Rather than looking at what the court said in a “top-down” analysis of the opinion, let’s look at how they fashioned their order, sending the matter back to the Court of Appeal to reconsider how to give the trial court direction about how to proceed further.
In its concluding paragraph to an opinion ranging over 42 pages, the majority perhaps provided a glimpse into the future, “Finally, one should not assume a sizeable new housing development planned for a site relatively far from major urban centers, to be built largely on undeveloped land with habitat for several sensitive species, will have comparatively minor impacts either on greenhouse gas emissions or on fish and wildlife.”
My interpretation of this sentence? The court’s not too thrilled with what NLF proposes and will judge it harshly.
A review of the opinion bears this out.
The justices revived two additional bases for critics of the development.
The opponents had claimed that the development would significantly impact both steelhead smolt and Native American cultural resources. These issues were not addressed because the lower court had held that the critics raised them too late in the process.
The Supreme Court went the other way, finding that these points had been timely raised. And, as such, they needed to be dealt with.
Of significance is the fact that six Indian tribes (including the Pechanga and the Pala, both of which have Las Vegas-style casinos) filed Amici Curiae (“Friends of the Court”) briefs with the Supreme Court in support of the opponents. If the Indian tribes decide to get deeply involved in the battle, they could contribute funds needed to continue the fight.
Added to that, NLF likely will have to more thoroughly address the steelhead smolt issue. Perhaps another fish controversy?
So, now NLF has these two issues along with greenhouse gas emissions and the stickleback fish. And the Court’s opinion provided little guidance to NLF on how to deal with these.
Discussion of greenhouse gas emissions consumed the bulk of the majority’s opinion, not the tiny fish.
If volume is an indicator of degree of concern, then NLF faces a real challenge. Because, essentially, the Supreme Court told both NLF and the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (DFW) that while part of their analysis of the greenhouse gas emission impact of the project was correct, it was fatally flawed.
Unfortunately, the court did not give clear guidance on what more is needed to be done. In fact, the court seemed to say that the DFW needs to produce guidelines on “evaluating a land use project’s impact on greenhouse gas emissions.” If NLF has to wait until the DFW has these guidelines, the delay could take years.
As for the unarmored threespine stickleback, the court simply said that DFW/NLF’s solution of moving the fish elsewhere was forbidden. So, it’s back to the drawing board on that one, too.
Based on these four controversies and the court’s concerns about the project, don’t hold your breath waiting for Newhall Ranch.
Carl Kanowsky of Kanowsky & Associates is an attorney in the Santa Clarita Valley. He may be reached by email at [email protected]. Mr. Kanowsky’s column represents his own views, and not necessarily those of The Signal. Nothing contained herein shall be or is intended to be construed as providing legal advice.
