“I’m Captain Moroni, from Utah.” So responded a “militiaman” holed up with Ammon Bundy’s revolutionary army at the remote Malheur National Wildlife Refuge in Oregon.
Say WHAT?
“And it came to pass that Moroni was angry with the government, because of their indifference concerning the freedom of their country.” Book of Mormon, Alma, 59:13.
Here we go again with zealots claiming special or “divine” grievance and mandate against established, lawful government. This time it’s not David Koresh or confused Muslims with machine guns – its old-school Nevada cowboy rancher Mormons with a long-running feud against the Federal Bureau of Land Management (BLM), who’ve twisted their religion into justification for flaunting serious federal laws ranging from fee evasion, to theft, to terrorism, to sedition.
Mormonism happens to be the vehicle for these criminals to justify their crimes. Raised in a distant, variant corner of Mormonism, alone on the Nevada plain, self reliant on the land they wish they owned but don’t actually do – perhaps these perpetrates actually believe the blather they’re slathering – but no matter.
The subject “faithful” antagonist-with-guns in this story is one Ammon Bundy, son of Cliven Bundy, antagonist-with-guns in the 2014 Bunkerville, Nevada armed stand off. “Like father like son,” the younger Ammon felt a duty to leave his stamp in history for the cause of freedom and justice, or, as the Book of Mormon’s Moroni himself wrote, “In memory of our God, our religion, and our freedom, and our peace…” – said verses often used at Bundy events.
Superficially, it sounds so good and warm and fuzzy and… American “freedomy” until you analyze what’s really going on. One needs to know Ammon Bundy was christened after another Book of Mormon figure, Ammon. That Ammon was an extraordinary righteous man, a great warrior, a faithful servant committed to justice. Ammon is living his “destiny.”
So here’s the recipe for this uniquely American armed religious fundamentalist extremism: Take one part rural individualist isolation, add fundamentalist ideology, mix in hard business times with unpaid back fees and taxes, and toss in scattered “scripture verses of your choice” to justify illegal actions against our constitutional government of laws. Bake this in desert heat for a few years and out pops Ammon Bundy, an attention-grabbing, Book of Mormon manipulating, sore losing, fanatic who just rounded up 150 armed “militiamen” who’ve taken a public facility hostage at gunpoint with threats to hold out for 30 years and “kill or be killed if things should come to that.” Their grievance this time is the 5 year prison sentence handed to fellow ranchers, Dwight and Steven Hammond for repeated arson on personal and federal lands. Boo hoo.
Following his dad’s footsteps, “righteous” Ammon found his own cause, gathered an armed “militia” and hijacked federal property. In his real, non-TV life, Ammon runs a limo service out of Phoenix, but that weakens the visuals he’s attempting with his armed assault. Right now, Ammon is playing the part of a genuine American “maverick,” fighting for the Constitution that’s been hijacked by a corrupt BLM.
So far, the Feds are playing a cool hand to avoid a Ruby Ridge outcome. But imagine the law enforcement response had 150 Black activists waving legal handguns taken over some courthouse protesting the injustice of the American over-criminalization of Blacks and minorities? Or how about our response had 150 Muslims brandishing legal semi-automatic machine guns closed down a passport processing office protesting anti-Muslim visa processes? One can see the police tanks and helicopters and likely B-52s circling with orders to shoot first, count the bodies later.
This time, it’s White confused Mormons who don’t like paying grazing fees or jail time for arson, waving guns, taking property, terrorizing neighbors, and twisting the religion of choice.
Meanwhile, you may not like your income tax rate. You may contest a property zoning. You hate the ticket you got last month. You disagree with the requirement to get vaccines for your kids. The list goes on. But – we live in a collective society with a collective structure and rules that govern our behavior. And you and I know we don’t wave weapons and take over police stations or schools or public works departments, even when we’re seriously pissed. It’s called, “civics.”
The LDS Church has issued formal statements separating themselves from Ammon Bundy’s actions. Local longtime LDS leaders (both lawyers) have also condemned the actions on Facebook. Rick Patterson: “Seeking liberty without obedience to the law is like baking cookies with baking soda instead of baking powder.” Robert Crockett: “These guys are felons and will have their guns taken away. This isn’t a case of religious freedom but ranchers wanting free or cheap federal land.”
In the end, Ammon Bundy is a story of a self-interested kid distorting religion to justify skipping personal responsibility to our collective community and rule of law. We now see with Western eyes how that religious trick of justification by faith is so readily accomplished. Tellingly, we also now witness how much more cautious and non-lethal our response to these felons are when the perpetrators are White Christians flying flags and chanting, “Liberty, god, and country” while brandishing their machine guns.
Ammon Bundy will not succeed in his “cause.” He will, however, have unintentionally educated Americans about our biased approach to justice and just how easy it is to twist nearly any religion towards self-justified armed insurrection.
Gary Horton is a Santa Clarita resident. “Full Speed to Port!” appears Wednesdays in The Signal.
