Lawsuits and threats of lawsuits began changing the face of local elections in 2015, and this year promises to see more changes brought on by claims that the previous method of balloting in the Santa Clarita Valley was discriminatory.
The first ballot to reflect the shift in elections was for the William S. Hart Union High School District’s election last November.
The result was confusion among voters, reduced voter turnout and, ironically, an incumbent booted out of office who is a member of the minority group the lawsuits aimed to help.
The Hart district was the first to conduct elections that shifted from at-large balloting — in which all voters within an agency’s boundaries can cast ballots for any qualified candidates — to those that divide the agency among voting areas.
In voting-area balloting, voters can select only one candidate to represent them, and the opportunity to do so rolls around every four years, rather than every two years.
Confusion
The change led to some campaign confusion — voters who didn’t know why they hadn’t received a ballot or why they couldn’t vote for both Hart district board seats.
“I will have someone who will tell me, ‘Oh, I’ll vote for you,’ and they’ll be in the Saugus or the Newhall area, so they can’t,” said Hart district board member Steve Sturgeon during campaigning.
Linda Storli, who won her first board term in the Nov. 3 balloting, said it took her “a lot of time when I’m talking to people to explain what’s happened.”
Though voting areas have been billed as a way to boost the electoral power of minority voters — specifically Latinos — November’s Hart board race saw Storli defeat longtime board incumbent Gloria Mercado-Fortine, a Latina.
Mercado-Fortine, who opposed the district’s move to voting areas in 2014, pins much of the blame for her loss on what she calls “dirty politics.”
But, she said, “the other factor was that there was no way that the way this was done, the way they broke up into districts, was going to help any minority, any Latino.”
“It just confirms why I voted ‘no’ for it,” she said. “It’s a complete failure, a complete failure — and I probably can be used as an example of that.”
One of the attorneys who brought the 2013 lawsuits — and threatened to file more based on claims Latinos weren’t given a fair voice in local elections — failed to respond to repeated requests for comments on the local election outcome.
Voter turnout
Meantime, voter turnout for Santa Clarita Valley elections sank below 10 percent for the Hart district election in November, as well as for a water district election conducted at large.
“It’s really a shame that, with 30,000 people, 2,200 people made the decision,” said Sturgeon, who won his bid to keep his seat against a contender in the voting area that takes in most of Canyon Country and parts of Saugus.
Turnout in that voting area was 8.3 percent; in the Hart District voting area where Storli and Mercado-Fortine faced off, the turnout was 9.6 percent.
Newhall County Water District’s at-large election saw a voter turnout of 9.6 percent. Countywide, the number stood at about 11 percent.
Whether the Hart district’s 2015 experience with voting-area elections is an outlier or an indicator will be seen in upcoming elections.
Elections are currently scheduled in 2017 in the Hart, Castaic Union, Newhall and Sulphur Springs school districts — all of them by voting areas.
New policy
Meantime, the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors has adopted a policy allowing them to approve more local agencies’ requests to move their elections from odd-numbered years — when ballots are mostly made up of local issues and voter turnout is low — to even-numbered years, when state and national races appear on the ballot and turnout tends to be higher.
Some have expressed hope that consolidating local elections with state and national races might draw more people to the polls to vote on local issues.
College of the Canyons and the Saugus Union School District will hold their first voting-area elections in November this year. They will appear on ballots crammed with high-profile state and federal elections, including the race to replace President Barack Obama.
The county’s policy change has also allowed the city of Santa Clarita to jettison its April elections in favor of a November contest. The first such race will also appear on the November 2016 ballot.
661-287-5525
On Twitter @LukeMMoney
