Combining water resources and cutting hefty court costs could mean favorable water rates for Santa Clarita Valley water users, according to the architects of a proposed water super-agency.
Stopping short of promising reduced rates or slowed rate increases with a proposed merger of water interests, officials representing the valley’s water wholesaler and importer — the Castaic Lake Water Agency — and the Newhall County Water District, one of three main SCV water retailers, said rates would reflect the merger’s “economies of scale.”
“We now have an opportunity of forming one agency that will create good economies of scale,” Bill Cooper, long-standing member of Castaic Lake’s board, told The Signal Editorial Board this week.
“Economies of scale” refers to a proportionate saving in costs gained through an increased level of production.
“We would have one engineering department, for example,” Cooper said. “So, by combining this and other resources, there are some opportunities there to save money.”
Asked how such savings would affect water rates, Cooper said: “It’s about customers and making sure the customer is our No. 1 priority.
“This (merger) has to benefit our customers,” he said.
Merging the agency and the district was announced as a possibility by both last week. Talks to arrange the move had been in the works for about a year.
Several districts
The Santa Clarita Valley has long had three primary water retailers from whom residents and businesses buy water. Founded in 1953, Newhall County is the oldest among the trio. The others are Santa Clarita Water Division and Valencia Water Company.
Recognizing that the area would need more water as it grows, local residents voted to create a wholesale water company in 1962, adding Castaic Lake Water Agency to the water mix so the valley could tap into State Water Project supplies from Northern California.
Castaic Lake sells wholesale water to the three retailers, supplying about 50 percent of the water currently used in the valley. The rest comes from wells.
In 1999 Castaic Lake acquired the stock of Santa Clarita Water Company, changing its name to the Santa Clarita Water Division. It took a new law to legalize the purchase, but that law was specific to the Santa Clarita Water purchase only, opponents to the takeover say.
In 2013 the agency purchased controlling shares of the Valencia Water Company and now controls that retailer, as well.
Newhall County Water District sued over the second acquisition, saying the Valencia Water purchase was illegal. That litigation is still pending.
‘One agency’
Three years ago Castaic’s board members called for one all-encompassing water agency. They called it “One valley, one vision, one water agency.”
Cooper echoed those sentiments Wednesday.
“When the city was formed we had four different water companies,” he said. “Is that really necessary? When we are the third largest city in Los Angeles County? Having one water company is an opportunity,” he said.
A merged agency-district entity, tentatively referred to as a water resource management agency, would be a historic shift in the control and management of the Santa Clarita Valley’s water.
Asked if staff reductions would result from a merger, Maria Gutzeit, a member of Newhall County’s board, said the new agency would reduce through attrition, not layoffs.
“We’ll be looking at areas for efficiency,” she said.
Litigation
Some of the cost savings, officials from both organizations said Wednesday, would result from the immediate elimination of all their costly court cases aimed at each other.
“With the existing structure, we had inherent discord,” said Newhall County board member Dan Mortensen.
“So, rather than settling this with a lawsuit, we thought, ‘How are we going to give our ratepayers a better playing field?’”
Would any significant money be saved if court battles were dropped?
“Yes,” Newhall County’s General Manager Steve Cole said.
“For any agency our size, it (eliminating court costs) is material,” he said. “So we started thinking, ‘Let’s throw everything out and build a new agency.’”
Officials also said that a combined agency would result in fewer outside consultants having to be hired. There would be more resources in-house on which to rely.
Not everyone on the Newhall water board is a fan of the proposed merger, though. Board member Lynne Plambeck said the proposed merger is “bad news for ratepayers.”
“I don’t think it serves this valley well to have a water monopoly, which is what’s going on here,” she said Friday.
Plambeck said Newhall functions very efficiently now — which may not be the case should it join to create a “big bureaucracy” Castaic Lake.
“All this would do for us is expose us to enormous expenses that we have, with efficiency and good oversight, been able to avoid,” she said.
She’s also concerned Newhall County consolidating with CLWA “violates the law the same way the Valencia Water acquisition did.”
“They’re going to lose out on their electoral power,’ she said of ratepayers, “lose out on their ability to control water rates, lose out on a very efficiently run water district.”
Those organizing the merger plan propose the water super-agency would initially be made up of the 10 Castaic Lake directors and the five Newhall County Water District directors. Those numbers might be reduced in the future, they said.
Not done deal
Every time a water official explained an aspect of, or shared a vision for, the proposed merger Wednesday, it was met with the footnote that the deal is tentative.
It could all fall apart like harmony at a family holiday meal, Gutzeit said.
“This is still a work in progress,” she said. “We’re like a family at Thanksgiving — if you bring up certain issues at the dinner table, everyone’s going to get bristly.”
661-287-5527
on Twitter @jamesarthurholt
