Some liked the idea of one big water agency serving the Santa Clarita Valley, some didn’t, but what they all agreed on at Thursday’s public workshop to study the proposed merger of competing water interests was that the public needs more information.
Santa Clarita Valley residents got a chance Thursday night to weigh in on a proposed water agency merger that promises to bring about a historic shift in the control and management of the valley’s water,
More than 100 people showed up Thursday night at the Santa Clarita Activities Center, on Centre Pointe Parkway, to participate in the first public workshop scheduled to discuss the proposed merger.
Officials representing the valley’s water wholesaler and importer — the Castaic Lake Water Agency — and the Newhall County Water District, one of three main SCV water retailers, announced their intentions to merge two weeks ago.
Representatives of both agencies have gone on the record saying the merger would consolidate resources, eliminate costly litigation cases between the two and, as a result, bode well for ratepayers concerned about the prospect of rate increases.
One of the first to call for more information on the merger, was Diane Trautman who serves on the city of Santa Clarita’s Planning Committee.
“I am concerned about a merger,” she said, speaking as an individual. “Perhaps, if there’s an umbrella organization that oversees individually elected boards that would be acceptable. But the transparency issue has been an ongoing complaint for many years, and that has to be addressed.
“There should be a forensic audit that reveals among other things, expenditures,” she said. “Everybody needs that information.”
Echoing the call for more information was former CLWA General Manager Robert Sagehorn, in favor of the merger.
“I encourage you to continue this very important process, and provide the public with all the information they need to see if this will be a workable solution,” he said.
Lynne Plambeck, longstanding member of the NCWD board, told the group: “I have adamantly opposed this (merger) suggestion because we have a very well functioning water district.
“We have a water district that represents the epitome of democracy,” she said. “You can walk the precinct and know who your actual constituents are.”
If the merger is about working together, she said, there are plenty of examples of a community of water agencies already working together.
“You know, we have an integrated water resource plan in this valley, and we’ve gotten a considerable amount of grants and several millions of dollars in grants towards recycled water.
“We work very well together,” she said. “We have an upper Santa Clara River Water Committee that meets, but we like having our independent water district.”
Plambeck was the first speaker to garner enthusiastic response from the attendees.
Ed Dunn, former president of the NCWD, opposed to the merger called for a legislative audit of the merger.
“The NCWD should in no way be united with the CLWA,” he said.
Ed’s wife, Joan, held up a collection of newspaper clippings which she said documented a history of the CLWA as “empire builders.” She asked the group: “Is that what we’re doing here with this merger?”
City Councilwoman Marsha McLean, who spoke Thursday as a Newhall County Water District customer, said she applauds the way CLWA “acquires water and banks water” but she added: “I am not a fan of consolidation.
“Ninety-nine percent of mergers never turn out to be a benefit for the consumer,” she said. “I need a lot more information.
“I would like to see one side tell me about it, and I would like to see the other side do the same,” she said. “But, right now, I do not have enough information.”
Speaker Theodore Regino addressed the specific point of litigation costs, striking a chord with attendees.
“If one of the rationales of the merger is that they want to settle litigation, it seems to me like a man and a woman who want to get married after they’ve been fighting for so long.
“Because if you marry to settle disputes, there will be more disputes,” he said. “That’s just my life experience.”
The Castaic Lake Water Agency supplies about half the water consumed in the Santa Clarita Valley, providing State Water Project water to the Newhall district along with Valencia Water Company and Santa Clarita Water Division.
The other approximately 50 percent of the water consumed locally comes from wells. The management of those wells and the rate-setting that comes with it have, over the years, sometimes pitted Castaic Lake against Newhall County and vice versa.
A merger would immediately kill the lawsuits and cap mounting legal costs tied to them, representatives from both agencies have said publicly.
661-287-5527
on Twitter @jamesarthurholt




