With regards to the boost in minimum wages to $10 per hour as of Jan. 1, probably the only real technical issue for California employers’ payroll was calculating correctly using the new wage amount.
But the biggest wage headache might come as firms ensure that their male and female workers are paid equally for “substantially similar” work, according to a new law that took effect in the state this year. It’s also the nation’s toughest law with regards to fair pay.
“The law isn’t that different than it has been at any other time; pay should have always been comparable,” said Sandi Malmquist, chair of district 12 of the Professionals In Human Resources Association in Santa Clarita. “Now it’s just official.”
Although, Gov. Jerry Brown didn’t come out with a lot of guidelines to help define “substantially similar” work, Malmquist said employers should review their compensation practices by taking a look at their job descriptions to see if a job is identical or very similar.
“They don’t want a wage discrimination claim against them based on male and female pay in the workplace,” she said.
A firm can take a look at factors such as seniority and how much people produce, said attorney Carl Kanowsky, but an employer also needs to conduct a line-by-line comparison of all job titles, job descriptions and males vs. females to see if they can spot any pay disparities.
“In any kind of wage and hour dispute, you want to have solid reasons for why something is done,” Kanowsky said. “You want something a lot more concrete than ‘Joe’s been with us a year longer and he’s a nice guy.’”
There are a lot of resources out there for companies to use for help in reviewing jobs that are similar and comparing what they pay, regardless of sex, he said.
To be proactive and protect a firm from a wage discrimination claim, Malmquist advises firms to fully investigate their current staff’s salaries.
“Talk to the managers and look at jobs to see what the comparisons are,” she said. “Review the compensation and make recommendations to the mangers to make sure compensation is fair and equitable.”
Kanowsky also advises companies to do market comparisons to make sure their salaries are competitive within their industry. If a company finds their salaries are fairly comparable, that’s good, but if a firm is paying a female employee 40 percent of what the industry typically pays in that job, it’s a good indication there may be a problem, he said.
Being proactive and getting ahead of a problem also has other advantages, besides avoiding a possible costly claim.
“One client has a female employee who was extremely valuable to their operation. They realized that and began to bring her salary up to others, commensurate with their level, and now she’s very appreciate,” Kanowsky said. “When you do it without someone complaining, then you look like an enlightened employer.”
Also, in the past, companies frequently asked their employees not to discuss their salaries with co-workers, but that is old-school, he said. Under the new law, employees can discuss their wages or benefits with other employees and employers are not allowed to discipline them for doing so, he said.
If an employee does raise a wage equality concern, the best thing to do is look at it and see if the concern is legitimate. If it is, address it quickly.
“Your first priority is to be honest. Don’t tell half-truths or outright lies,” he said. “You’ll get found out and that can really hurt you with employees or later on in front of the labor commissioner or in front of a jury.”
