Some parents claim a new internal lottery admission process used to promote Albert Einstein Academy sixth-grade students to the public charter school’s junior high is unfair due to a policy that gives preference to certain students, including children of board members.
The board has agreed to redo the lottery but says its policy is not illegal.
Albert Einstein students and parents packed a special meeting in Valencia Thursday night to complain to the board of directors about the handling of the admissions process.
“All I want is a fair lottery, not just for me but all my peers,” said sixth-grader Justin Jimenez, who was placed on the waitlist to get into the junior high school next year.
Some parents allege school representatives told them their children would be guaranteed a spot in the seventh grade class if they attended the elementary school. Len Unkeless, a parent of a fourth-grader, said parents were told that their students would get a spot at the junior high before they enrolled at the elementary school.
“Keep your promises,” Unkeless told the board “You made it. You need to keep it.”
Marcia Sharp, the board’s secretary, told the parents Thursday that having preferences in the lottery is allowed under state law.
The board said a lottery process was needed this year because the public charter schools do not have enough slots for everyone who applied to attend the charter’s junior high school.
Board members determined in closed session Thursday that the lottery was invalid, but said human errors were to blame for state law not being followed, Sharp said on Friday.
“We had some human errors and some incorrect information so it has to be redone according to state law, unfortunately,” Sharp said. Another lottery is scheduled for Thursday.
Sharp said they must redo the lottery because school officials incorrectly believed two students were siblings based on them sharing the same name and because a child of an employee was placed on the waitlist.
Albert Einstein Academy’s charter documents allow the school to give first preference to sixth-graders with siblings already at Albert Einstein’s junior high and high schools, children of board members, and children of employees at any Albert Einstein Academy site.
Those policies left many parents feeling frustrated.
“Just because you can, doesn’t mean you should,” said Vivian Kimoto, a parent of a sixth-grade student who was put on the waitlist.
So why does the school have a lottery for admission?
The charter school’s junior high and high school campuses have more applicants than students they can accept due to space constraints, Sharp said.
School officials determined they could only take 75 seventh-grade students next year. About 40 of the slots in the first lottery results were filled by siblings of students at the junior and high school campus, Sharp said.
Charter schools are public schools and will accept all students who want to attend. However, if there are more students who want to attend than seats available, a charter school will use a process, oftentimes a lottery, to randomly select students. This year marks the first time the junior high school had to use a lottery.
Sharp said parents were informed at the beginning of the current school year that a lottery must be conducted because they had more students than slots.
