Despite critics alleging the local sanitation board would break the law if it approved a heavily tweaked environmental report, board members unanimously did just that.
The three-member Santa Clarita Valley Sanitation District board approved two resolutions Wednesday night giving the Sanitation District a green light to move forward on both an altered environmental impact report and the larger four-year plan to reduce chloride contamination of the Santa Clara River.
At issue was the interpretation of a court ruling issued late last month by Judge James C. Chalfont in response to a lawsuit filed by a group of unhappy SCV ratepayers called the Affordable Clean Water Alliance.
Alliance members and their supporters told the board publicly that last month’s court ruling nullifies the district’s chloride-reducing plan — approved by the state in October 2013 — since the judge “set aside,” or tossed out, its cornerstone document, the environmental impact report.
When all the speakers finished warning the board it would be breaking the law and violating conditions of the California Environmental Quality Act, board members followed lawyers into the back room for a closed-door session.
Ten minutes later they emerged and told the dozen people gathered at Santa Clarita City Hall for the meeting that they were not breaking the law and were moving forward.
“It is the opinion of district counsel that the agenda items before the board this evening with regard to that project are in compliance with the court’s rulings and with CEQA,” district counsel spokesman Wes Beverlin said.
“The court’s decision found only two facets of the 2013 EIR to be at variance with CEQA,” he said. “The court required additional study of (unarmored threespine) stickleback fish populations if the district were to significantly reduce its discharge of treated wastewater to the Santa Clara River.
“To avoid delays in meeting the state’s compliance deadline, the water reuse component is not being recommended as part of the project,” Beverlin said.
Dropping the recycled water component from the district’s EIR did not sit well with several speakers.
“We’re jumping the gun,” said Al Ferdman. “We really need to have that recycle component in the plan; otherwise, it is a disservice to ourselves.”
ACWA member Flo Lawrence told the board: “It astounds me that the district is choosing to ignore the clear requirements of the (judge’s) writ.
“It seems to me we have to honor the court’s instructions,” he said. “Don’t delete the recycled water component.”
Attorney Susan L. Durbin, of the Pasadena-based environmental law firm hired by the ACWA, told the board: “CEQA requires that the entire project and its EIR be set aside. It cannot be chopped up into little pieces.
“It will not work,” she said. “It is not lawful.”
On a positive note, Durbin recommended the board “get a stay — or an extension — and go back to the drawing board” for a completely new plan on reducing chloride.
ACWA member Allan Cameron said: “Recycled water was to be made available to the people of the Santa Clarita Valley.”
Lynne Plambeck urged the board simply: “I hope you will not destroy the river.”
The battle over chloride — a component of common table salt — discharged into the Santa Clara River has been waged for decades. In 1989 state regulators determined the component of salt must be reduced to an extremely low level due to salt-sensitive crops grown downstream.
Critics have challenged the science behind that argument and said the expensive process of reducing chloride from wastewater is unnecessary.
In 2010 SCV Sanitation District directors rejected a costly chloride reduction plan, risking fines from the state. In 2013 it adopted a less expensive plan.
The environmental impact report that supports that plan was challenged in the Affordable Clean Water Alliance lawsuit.
661-287-4427
on Twitter
@jamesarthurholt

