On March 22, The Signal published a column written by Enaya Hanbali entitled “It’s time to raise minimum wage.” Since then, the state Legislature and the governor have agreed to do so.
As noted by Hanbali, there is a huge emotional appeal to increasing the minimum wage.
For decades, the federal minimum wage levels have not kept pace with inflation, and many labor advocates rightly say this is not fair to workers. This debate is occurring at a time when the middle class is under pressure and the global economy is trending toward wealth concentration.
Perhaps the gap between the wealthy and poor is increasing because we are able to produce more goods and services with fewer jobs.
Last year, the Department of Labor produced a report comparing the economic output in 1998 with that of 2013. It can be found at: http://www.bls.gov/opub/btn/volume-3/what-can-labor-productivity-tell-us-about-the-us-economy.htm.
In 1998, the U.S. business sector worked 194 billion hours producing about $9 trillion of goods and services. In 2013, after adjusting for inflation, the U.S. business sector produced about $13 trillion of goods and services.
Interestingly, in 2013 the human labor worked in connection with that production remained at 1998 levels of 194 billion hours.
So, although there was a 43 percent growth in the amount of goods and services produced, the growth did not result from additional labor.
That means the middle class, who has traditionally benefited from economic growth, has sat on the sidelines while entrepreneurs and investors have reaped the benefits. Simply stated, technology is replacing jobs.
The politicians cannot stop that tend, so they make up artificial issues to campaign on while ignoring the proverbial elephant in the parlor.
Unfortunately, raising the minimum wage is a “feel good” short-term solution that may very well make the long term problem worse.
For example, robotics and artificial intelligence technology that will revolutionize the fast-food industry already exist. Once implemented, this technology is expected to reduce the labor requirements of a typical fast-food restaurant by 80 percent.
Existing technology allows computers to take the order, collect the amount paid by the customer and make change. (Think of the self-service checkout in your local supermarket.)
The ability to measure and cook the food and to deliver the finished meal to the customer through automation also exists, but the technology is presently too expensive to implement.
But implementation is expected to be cost effective within 10 years. So by 2025, many fast-food entry-level jobs will simply be gone.
This could occur sooner if wages increase relative to the productivity of the workers.
The cost of technology drops rapidly over time. Compare the capabilities of your smartphone with those of your personal computer from 10 years ago. Then compare the cost of a smartphone to the cost of that computer.
It is only a matter of time until the cost of job replacing technology becomes cost-effective to implement. Unfortunately, increasing labor costs will merely accelerate the trend.
Based on the economic results of the last 15 years, automation has happened in many industries, as evidenced by the increased production without any incremental labor hours. This trend is only going to accelerate.
Remember Bill Clinton and Al Gore bragging about the information super highway and all the jobs it was going to create? Well, it did create jobs — just not in America, because now we can outsource white-collar jobs as well as blue-collar jobs.
The information super highway will also be an essential component to the automation of jobs.
I don’t mean to knock Clinton and Gore, but this shows that you have to consider the long-term implications of a short-term success.
Similarly, well-intentioned politicians who seek to increase the minimum wage have to consider the long-term implications to a labor force that is becoming obsolete.
The deployment of the Internet unleashed the ability to create a harsh global economy. As a result, we have a system that increasingly rewards innovation and investment while decreasing the rewards of performing routine personal services.
The challenge in eliminating economic inequality is to reduce the gap without making everyone poor.
The key is to grow the middle class. We need to buy time to figure out how to do this, but if we increase labor costs the window of opportunity will close sooner.
The problem is that no politician is willing to pay the short-term price for the long-term gain.
Unless we find a way to redeploy workers into more productive endeavors, the innovators and investors are going to have to pick up an increased share of society’s burdens, and we may very well fall into the socialist trap of making everyone poor.
James P. de Bree is a Valencia resident.
