Several elected officials warned Friday that the state should not rush to allow the Aliso Canyon storage field to reopen following reports that blackouts could occur in Southern California this summer.
The Southern California Gas Co. said Thursday that the natural gas storage field, which remains closed after a monthslong leak, could reopen by late summer. A day later, policymakers expressed skepticism about that timeline at a joint agency workshop held in Woodland Hills.
“I don’t assume Aliso Canyon will be back on line this year, this winter, next winter. I assume we won’t know until DOGGR’s done with their studies,” Michael Picker, president of the California Public Utilities Commission, said in reference to the Division of Oil, Gas & Geothermal Resources.
Friday’s workshop – led by the Public Utilities Commission, California Independent System Operator and Los Angeles Department of Water and Power – was held to discuss an action plan that says the Aliso Canyon blowout could lead to blackouts over as many as 14 days this summer.
Rep. Brad Sherman, D-Sherman Oaks, who lives in the area of Porter Ranch affected by the leak, said the state should not be forced to make a decision between unsafe storage of gas and blackouts.
“Before county health officials have said our carpets and drapes are safe to be in the same house, we’re told neighbors must move back and we’re having a hearing about injecting more gas into the field,” he said.
Sherman accused SoCalGas of “negligence” and said the utility’s plan does not do enough to ensure other aging wells do not fail.
“They want modest short-term improvements in safety, no long-term improvements in safety and a return to business as usual and to pass all costs on to consumers,” he said.
Los Angeles City Councilman Mitch Englander, who also lives in the area, called the situation an “ongoing tragedy.”
“Either they inject gas into their facility that has not yet been independently inspected or declared safe, posing an immediate risk to thousands of local residents or we endure scheduled rolling blackouts in a region known for its extreme temperatures during the summer months, potentially risking the lives of our most vulnerable,” Englander said.
Paula Cracium, president of the Porter Ranch Neighborhood Council, said residents in the small Los Angeles community do not want blackouts, but she said another leak would have even worse consequences.
“The risk of possible blackouts cannot outweigh the possible risk of another catastrophic incident,” she said.
More than 6,000 people in Porter Ranch were displaced from their homes, and many residents claim to have suffered symptoms including nosebleeds and headaches.
No plans to reopen
State Oil and Gas Supervisor Ken Harris said they have 21 engineers working full time at the site and there are no plans to allow Aliso Canyon to reopen at this time.
Public Utilities Commissioner Catherine Sandoval also tried to reassure residents that they would make sure all rules are followed before allowing work to resume at the site.
Aliso Canyon is the largest natural gas storage area in the West and provides fuel for heat in winter and helps power electric plants in summer when energy demand spikes for cooling. Ample storage is needed because natural gas pipelines can’t deliver gas fast enough or carry the capacity needed to meet high demands.
During the leak, the company withdrew most of the gas in the field to relieve pressure on the leaking well and it’s under order from state regulators not to store additional gas deep underground until all 114 remaining wells pass a battery of strict tests.
State agencies studying the impact of the Aliso Canyon incident developed an action plan which they concluded “will reduce, but not eliminate, the risk of gas shortages this summer that are large enough to cause electricity interruptions for the region’s residents and businesses.”
The outages could affect Los Angeles to San Diego counties. The projection of 14 blackout days is based on a typical summer, meaning the number could be more or less depending on weather. An additional 18 blackout days could occur later in the year.
Conserving energy
Lawmakers are considering incentives to encourage Californians to save energy this summer.
“Energy reliability can be obtained by conservation and ramping up renewable energy supplies,” said state Sen. Fran Pavley, D-Agoura Hills.
Consumers may be asked to cut back electricity and gas usage on certain days, but Picker says that strategy is only effective for short periods of time.
Picker added that solar thermal heating – roof panels used to heat water storage tanks – and electric water heaters would help reduce energy usage. He said it’s up to local government agencies to develop incentive programs to encourage energy-saving measures.
“The challenge is of course that means people got to get rid of their gas water heaters and replace them. I can’t make them do that,” he said.
