A former principal and a former teacher of Castaic Elementary School – witnesses for the prosecution – testified Monday that they sought Joshua Levine’s help for each of their respective children.
Levine, 43, a fourth-grade teacher at Castaic Elementary School, is on trial on charges of misdemeanor inappropriate touching of four 10-year-old female students during the 2014-15 school year.
On Monday, lawyers for both the defense and the prosecution finished presenting evidence in the trial.
Jurors were given their instructions by Commissioner Jeffrey M. Harkavy. Closing arguments are scheduled to be made Tuesday morning, after which jurors are expected to begin their deliberations.
The last two witnesses were women who once worked with Levine at Castaic Elementary School.
Former Principal Rhonda Steinberg told the court she documented nine complaints made against Levine between 1999 and 2003. Two of those complaints were from parents, six from teachers and one from an officer staffer.
Deputy District Attorney Julie Kramer asked Steinberg if she had to advise Levine not to engage in any inappropriate contact with students.
“Yes, I did,” Steinberg said.
Under cross-examination, defense attorney Todd Melnick asked Steinberg if two of the nine complaints pertained to comments Levine had made “about two pretty moms” at the school.
“Correct,” she said.
Melnick also asked her: “Did Mr. Levine tutor your son in chemistry?”
Steinberg said “no” until Melnick refreshed her memory with a “thank you" note she had written to Levine.
“Brad (son) did a lesson, and he helped him,” she said.
Melnick asked her if she also thanked Levine for taking the time to help new students.
“Yes, I did,” she said.
Former first-grade teacher Laura Kubler testified about her role analyzing data pertaining to the academic development of students at Castaic Elementary, including data related to the students in Levine’s class.
When Kramer asked what she noticed about the results pertaining to Levine’s students, Kubler said: “There was little or no growth.”
Kubler was asked if she discussed the results with Levine.
“Yes, as a team. And he would often get upset and go to the administration to complain,” Kubler said.
Melnick asked her: “Did Levine help your child?”
“Yes, on one occasion,” she said.
Melnick also asked her if she sought help from Levine in his capacity as a representative of the teacher’s union.
She said she had.
Melnick asked if she had sent Levine a “thank you” note for having helped her.
She said yes.
661-287-5527
on Twitter @jamesarthurholt

