The fate of a local fourth-grade teacher accused of inappropriately touching four 10-year-old female students during the 2014-15 school year is now in the hands of the jury.
Joshua Mark Levine, a 43-year-old teacher at Castaic Elementary School, who never testified in his own defense, is charged with misdemeanor inappropriate touching of four female students in his class.
After more than two weeks of testimony, lawyers for both the defense and the prosecution used an entire day at the Santa Clarita Courthouse to make their closing arguments to the jury.
When those arguments wrapped up at 4:20 p.m. Tuesday, Commissioner Jeffrey M. Harkavy instructed the jury of eight women and four men to begin deliberating until 4:30 p.m.
At one point during his closing argument, Levine’s defense lawyer Todd Melnik told the jury: “You guys should be in and out (of deliberation) within 10 minutes.”
As it turned out, deliberations are now expected to resume at 9 a.m. Wednesday.
Closing arguments got underway Tuesday morning with Deputy District Attorney Julie Kramer telling jurors Levine is a sexual predator.
“He violated the trust of his students. He violated the trust of the community, and he violated the trust of the parents,” she said. “Why? Why did he do this?
“It’s not because he was a goofy sarcastic guy as the defense lawyer told you. It’s because he couldn’t control himself.
“He was told over and over and over again not to touch his kids, yet he continued to engage in that sort of behavior.”
Using a computer-projected overhead screen, Kramer itemized the testimony of each child, addressing three specific complaints common to each of the alleged victims: tickling, massaging of shoulders and lap sitting.
In reviewing the testimony of one of the four alleged victims, Kramer said: “She was crying because it was something hard for her relive.”
To dramatically illustrate the time one child reportedly sat on Levine’s lap – or knees – Kramer counted 16 seconds out loud in front of the jury.
“Sixteen seconds is a long time,” she said, counting each second.
When it came time to present his case, Melnik used the same methodical approach of breaking down the testimony of each witness in point form with the use of an overhead projector.
“This is not a case about a pedophile. This is not a child molestation case – not even close,” he said.
“The DA talked about compulsion and preying on children. We’re talking about the end of school – where’s the goal?
“Mr. Levine is never alone with any child. Which throws incredible doubt about the sexual nature of his actions. What was the end goal? The kids were never alone with him.
“This case is ridiculously overblown.”
The defense lawyer reminded the jury that his client never spent time with students after school and always kept the door of his classroom unlocked.
“Did he really do something criminal here? I pray to God that the answer is ‘No,’” he said.
Melnik asked the jury to consider why the teacher who was first told about the complaint by a student never testified in court.
“There’s nothing. She wasn’t on the witness list. Why wasn’t she called?” he said.
The teacher in question notified former Castaic Elementary School Principal Denise Davis, who then carried out her own investigation and then notified deputies of the Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff’s Station.
Melnik also questioned, in his closing remarks, why none of the interviews done with the alleged victims by educators and Sheriff’s detectives had not been recorded.
It is Melnik’s contention that the alleged lap-sitting was actually knee-sitting and that it was knee-sitting which – most times – was not tolerated.
“They (interviewers) could have asked, ‘Where did you sit?’ These questions were never asked until we got here. And, if these questions were asked, there’s no record of it,” he said.
661-287-5527
on Twitter @jamesarthurholt

