The California Legislature appears poised to lead an attack on the First Amendment with a set of bills currently moving their way through the capitol.
Assembly Bill 1671 by Jimmy Gomez, D-Los Angeles, would make it a crime to distribute an unlawfully recorded conversation.
If the recording was unlawfully obtained, then a crime has certainly been committed, you might say. And you’re right. That violation of the penal code will result in punishment if the perpetrator is caught and convicted.
But distributing that recording is a different matter, officials at the California Newspaper Publishers Association (CNPA) point out.
Distribution of an illegally obtained recording has never been a crime in this state and it’s not a crime anywhere else because the U.S. Supreme Court has ruled that laws criminalizing the distribution of content are almost always unconstitutional.
If passed, this legislation can be challenged in court the day it is law. Such a challenge could cost the state money pointlessly defending against a patently illegal bill.
A second challenge to the First Amendment can be found in Assembly Bill 2533, authored by Los Angeles Democrat Miguel Santiago.
This measure would require a police agency to wait at least five days before releasing police body camera footage to the public. During that delay, the officer whose body camera recorded the incident could seek to block release of the footage all together.
“AB2533 would allow a self-interested individual to have a stranglehold over information that the public has an overwhelming interest in obtaining and that a law enforcement agency may want to disclose immediately for the good of the community,” wrote James W. Ewert, general counsel for the CNPA.
The bill, if passed, would be a “radical departure” from the California Public Records Act, which provides access to information for both journalists and the public, Ewert said.
The state’s Right to Record Act reaffirms the public’s right to put audio and video recording into public discourse, yet AB2533 would stifle public agencies’ access to that same public discourse, “handcuffing state and local law enforcement agency discretion.”
Frankly, we find this duo of anti-First Amendment bills to be puzzling contradictions to California’s track record of championing public access – a record dating back to at least 1953, when the Ralph M. Brown Act was approved, and continuing up to 2015’s approval of the Right to Record Act.
We hope you will join us in opposing both Gomez’s AB1671 and Santiago’s AB2533 – and put California back on track as a leader in the cause of transparency.
Contact Assemblyman Gomez at 916-319-2051 and Assemblyman Santiago at 916-319-2053.
