I read the Friday Signal article on Valencia Water Company’s proposed surcharge increase. Unfortunately, Valencia Water Company’s general manager, Ken Petersen, only provided a partial justification for the increase.
Most people may not be aware that Valencia Water Company also justifies the pass-through of its costs and revenue shortfalls based in part on achieving a 7.2 percent rate of return.
Compare that to the negative 0.73 percent return for the S&P 500 last year and you may have a much different picture about the appropriateness of this surcharge increase.
Mr. Petersen did not discuss Valencia Water Company’s guaranteed return because the water utility is a privately held (owned by Castaic Lake Water Agency) corporation that isn’t required to disclose its financials.
It is clear that Valencia Water Company is a monopoly when it comes to providing water to the communities it serves in the Santa Clarita Valley.
Historically, Valencia Water Company has had the ability to pass through all of its costs and revenue shortfalls without providing its customers sufficient financial information to adequately ascertain the reasonableness of such increases.
The existing process only serves to disenfranchise the public and bolster concerns over the water utility governance process.
Therefore, in order to ensure the integrity of the governance process, Valencia Water Company should be compelled to fully disclose its financials and justify the reasonableness of any guaranteed profits as part of any rate or surcharge increase.
