Valencia High pitcher Shea O’Leary, standing beside catcher Allysa Shipman outside their school’s softball diamond last week, had just finished detailing why she’d chosen to pitch rather than catch, when Vikings assistant Dan Ramos chimed in.
“You guys sound like Mike Trout right now,” Ramos teased from the home dugout, referencing the Los Angeles Angels star outfielder.
“Dan, stop listening in, come on,” Shipman said, feigning irritation.
“Too professional,” Ramos continued, “way too professional for high school students.
“‘Yes, I’ve been doing this for 50 years,’” he mocked. “‘I feel really good right now. I’ve always been meant to be in that circle.’ You guys are a kick.”
O’Leary and Shipman giggled.
It’s hard to remember that one of the most talented pitcher-catcher duos in the CIF-Southern Section’s Division 1 consists of sophomores.
Other times, it’s more believable, like when they partake in pregame dance parties or when teammates describe them as goofy.
One thing was clear to everyone when the two came together last season: the potential for something special.
As O’Leary and Shipman continue to develop, the Santa Clarita Valley’s last playoff softball team standing only grows more dangerous, and the lanky flamethrower and cerebral softball-masher aren’t going anywhere anytime soon.
“It’s helped us tremendously,” Valencia senior Alley Johnson says of Shipman and O’Leary’s development. “For one, everything starts with a pitcher and a catcher.”
O’Leary, 15, and Shipman, 16, don’t remember the day they met. But they do recall taking a picture together at a tournament in Colorado sometime before their high-school careers began.
In the age of selfies, it was a seemingly trivial moment, but, apparently, a seminal one.
They began talking more often, discussing futures at Valencia High.
Vikings head coach Donna Lee knew they were coming.
She’d known of Shipman for years because Shipman’s sister, Madison, played for Valencia from 2007 to 2010, winning four Foothill League titles and a prep national championship before starring at shortstop for the University of Tennessee and competing professionally.
“We used to call her ‘Canoe’ — little Ship was coming,” Lee says of Allysa.
Allysa and Madison, 23, didn’t particularly get along when Madison was in high school. But, as so often is the case, the relationship improved when the older sister left for college.
Allysa traveled to Tennessee for Madison’s bridal shower earlier this month and calls her when she’s having a bad day.
“She’s definitely one of my idols,” Allysa says. “It’s weird to say that because she’s my sister.”
Still, even after committing to Tennessee as an eighth-grader, Allysa isn’t content in Madison’s shadow.
“If somebody’s like, ‘Are you going to be better than your sister?’ I’m not afraid to be like, ‘Yeah,’” Allysa says.
While it’s too early for an overall comparison, Allysa’s freshman numbers were better than Madison’s.
The younger Shipman hit .506 with 10 home runs and 35 RBIs en route to All-CIF-SS Division 1 honors (Madison hit .276 with two home runs and nine RBIs in 2007).
“Just the fact that she is living up to the hype of her sister is a huge accomplishment,” says Jim Ziese, who coached Allysa for two years with the Santa Clarita Valley-based So Cal Choppers travel team. “The sky is the limit for that kid.”
You can see, then, how tantalizing the pairing of Shipman and O’Leary, a University of Texas commit, must have been for Valencia.
At 6 feet 2 inches tall, O’Leary looks the part of an intimidator, even more so behind the non-prescription sunglasses she wears during games because she hates visors.
She has the stuff to back it up, too, pitching in the low to mid 60s, with a dynamic drop curve, screwball and rise ball. But while Shipman, who regularly played above her age group growing up, took to the high-school game immediately, O’Leary needed time to find dominating form.
She posted a 3.54 ERA in 200-plus innings in 2015, and Valencia’s Johnson was hard on her, pushing her to work even harder and mature.
“I scared her a little bit,” Johnson says.
That relationship is a good benchmark of how far the wunderkind has come.
Johnson says O’Leary has grown as a person and as a pitcher, someone who doesn’t need a senior’s chiding.
That doesn’t mean O’Leary isn’t still a little goofy.
“She’s always super hyper and excited about everything,” Shipman says of O’Leary. “She’ll start dancing and running around.”
Not always with grace, either.
O’Leary is a self-described klutz who was once nicknamed “Baby Giraffe” and is still growing into her lanky frame.
“Today she tripped in the weight room, almost went face first into the weights,” says Vikings senior first baseman Brittney Ross-Smith. “… That’s like a daily occurrence.”
Another trait intrinsic to O’Leary is positivity. “The happiest kid on Earth,” as Lee describes her, is quick to assure a teammate there will be another at bat.
O’Leary hasn’t always applied that sunny outlook to herself, though, so back-to-back rough outings early in league play this season provided a wake-up call.
Lee and Shipman preached a need for a better presence in the circle. The girl who chose to pitch as a 6-year-old so she could be the center of attention needed to own the moment.
And she did.
O’Leary allowed just eight hits over her next four league starts, and she has a 1.86 ERA on the season.
In 184 2/3 innings, she’s struck out 202 batters and walked 39.
“(As a pitcher) everybody relies on me kind of, sort of,” O’Leary says. “If I’m having a bad day, then everybody else does. I need to have that good day so everybody else does.”
O’Leary, too, has an NCAA Division 1 role model in the family.
Her mom, Carrie, caught at Wichita State University, and as Carrie has seen Shea’s velocity and movement increase (Carrie eventually had to dig shin guards out of the attic to catch Shea’s bullpens), she has also has seen her daughter’s maturity flourish.
“She just has more poise on the mound,” Carrie says.
O’Leary is more willing, now, to shake off Shipman, who began calling her own game behind the plate in seventh grade.
Mostly they’re on the same page.
There’s a confidence O’Leary and Shipman (who is hitting a team-best .438) have in each other. It’s a confidence that extends to a young Valencia core.
Six freshmen saw playing time for the Vikings last season (Shipman, O’Leary, Kyla Hardy, Alexis Genovese, Noel Dominguez and Kelia Paragas). That group is more self-assured now, more battled tested.
You combine them with veterans like Ross-Smith, Johnson and senior second baseman Erin Andris and you have a squad that built on last year’s second-place finish by winning a share of the Foothill League title this season, Valencia’s first since 10 straight crowns from 2001 to 2010.
More importantly, the Vikings are playing their best softball: They’ve outscored their last eight opponents by a 74-5 mark, including a 3-0 win Thursday over Diamond Ranch of Pomona in the first round of the CIF-SS D1 playoffs.
Even if the Vikings (20-9) don’t exact revenge on Pacifica of Garden Grove (20-4) on Tuesday in the second round (the Mariners beat Valencia, 9-0, in the second round last year), the window to win with O’Leary and Shipman as the building blocks is hardly shut.
Ziese says Shipman’s physical tools and unparalleled work ethic could allow her to exceed even her sister’s ability.
O’Leary, everyone agrees, hasn’t hit her peak performance yet, either.
“We know how good we potentially could be,” Shipman says, “and we want to fully embrace that.”


