In exactly one year since the Santa Clarita Valley Business Journal first documented, and published, a detailed special report on the lack of access to high speed Internet services for businesses in the region, little progress has been made to develop a cohesive, strategic plan to build up the infrastructure. Progress to date has taken place in silos – by private parties making piecemeal attempts to patch service together.
One such case is the owners of the Mann Biomedical Park, who invested tens of thousands of dollars in their effort to build a world class business park by negotiating a fiber deal with Time Warner, committing to deliver a number of tenants as customers to the provider.
“We paid to bring it to the park,” said President Dale Donohoe of Intertex. “We were quoted $150,000, but got down to the ballpark of (paying) tens of thousands less by showing them the number of businesses they’d have hooking up to it.”
Recognizing the importance of offering the high-speed connection as an incentive to attract other firms to the business park – already home to Boston Scientific, Bioness, and the Alfred Mann Foundation – Donohoe said bringing in a high-speed connection to the park was critical to its success.
“We were able to show Time Warner they’d get their money back over time (by hooking the park up to fiber),” Donohoe said. “We showed them they’d have a future revenue stream.”
But, the effort to connect businesses is spotty and continues to occur one tenant, building or business center at a time.
Outdated technology
After multiple business owners said last year that the lack of access to high speed Internet in the Santa Clarita Valley was a serious problem for their firms, hampering efforts to conduct business, the Valley Industry Association convened its Advocacy Committee to look at the problem, attempting to find solutions for some of its members. The cost for individual businesses to solve the problem alone was often unaffordable, in some cases exceeding the cost of their rent.
The lack of modern day technology drove many business owners to actually curtail tasks performed by employees during certain times of the day, and others shifted work to their homes where they found higher upload speed with their residential service than at their business. Many firms were operating on old, outdated technology, including DSL or by cobbling T1 lines together to get by. Yet, Santa Clarita is the third largest city in Los Angeles County.
“We’re still working to address the lack of high speed Internet in the industrial parks, but there are no quick solutions,” said Kathy Norris, CEO and president of the Valley Industry Association. “Time Warner has made some strides in the affected areas, and both fiber and coax are available in several areas that didn’t have that type of service available previously. But, it’s a slow process.”
Hit and miss
VIA itself experienced multiple problems when it was located on Avenue Tibbitts. The industry group finally moved to Smyth Drive. Ironically, its old headquarters now has fiber available in the building – installed too late for VIA.
Other businesses on Avenue Tibbitts and Avenue Scott in the Valencia Industrial Center – located in the heart of the City of Santa Clarita – have finally been connected, and a small number of companies on Avenue Hopkins have been hooked up as well, Norris reports.
“Time Warner does ask that those folks sign a two- or three-year contract with them, however, to help them with their return on investment,” Norris said. “It is a costly process to continue with fiber. Some of the older areas of the Valencia Industrial Center are still struggling, however. And other companies on Rye Canyon, Beale Court, the north end of Avenue Hopkins, etc., still don’t have high speed services available to them.”
Newer business park
The struggle to get accurate answers also frustrates many of the business owners. Attorney Carl Kanowsky of Kanowsky & Associates, also a member of the VIA Advocacy Committee, said he’s been given so many conflicting answers as to what is or is not available from the providers, he’s not sure who or what information to trust.
Located on Summit Circle in a newer business park, Kanowsky’s firm still operates using a DSL connection. After several years of asking about upgrade options, Kanowsky now thinks he may be close to getting a coax connection, which is not as good as fiber but far better than a DSL line; and it appears rates are going down. But, he doesn’t want to count on it until he can see it proven, he said.
“We need to provide the infrastructure to increase the attractiveness and desirability to firms relocating up here, especially the entertainment and hi-tech industries,” he said. “It’s one of the prime concerns to people in those industries.”
Infrastructure
But, connecting isn’t all that simple. There are two major roadblocks to adding the infrastructure to existing business centers. The cost for providers to build fiber connections isn’t cheap, with the city requiring utilities to be placed underground. Thus, providers need to ensure multiple tenants in a building want their services before they commit so that they can get a return on their investment.
The second obstacle is a far bigger problem for the region. If a business is located within the City of Santa Clarita limits, the city does have excess fiber available, referred to as dark fiber because it is not being used, for private leases. It’s available along major roads in parts of the city, said Benny Ives, senior analyst with the city’s IT department.
Currently, the city runs 96-strand count fiber cables through major roadways in a large portion of the city to connect city facilities and manage traffic lights. And it has plans to more than double that capacity by running 192-strand fiber cables in future areas of the city. It can lease two to six strands at a time to private users. But, building a city-wide network is a much bigger problem to tackle.
“We would like to try to get AT&T and Time Warner to step up and provide more infrastructure on their own,” said City Manager Ken Striplin.
2020 Plan
But, the city also included the topic in its 2020 plan last year and formed an internal team to look at the challenge of building its own infrastructure, similar to how Santa Monica and other cities have done.
“In terms of economic development, it’s a significant issue,” said Mayor Bob Kellar. “There are pockets of the city with it and without it. In a perfect world, this entire city and world would have access to it.”
However, while acknowledging a solution is important, he said there haven’t been any recent developments that’s he heard of. The biggest problem for the city to build some kind of infrastructure itself, according to Ives with city’s IT department, is that Santa Clarita’s fiber connections essentially end – in Santa Clarita. Much like running a train, track has to be laid down from point A to point B. It would need to find a way to connect to One Wilshire – the west coast Southern California center where all carriers come into, he said.
“The question is how do we get it (the fiber) to downtown Los Angeles,” Ives said. “We also have to look at the type of equipment we need, the costs, staff resources required, and options available to us.”
2020 Plan
High speed Internet connections are an item in the city’s 2020 plan in which the city set forth two objectives under the “Enhancing Economic Vitality” section: (1) “Work with the EDC to provide recommendations and strategies on how to ensure high-speed Internet access to business parks;” and (2) “Establish a revenue-generating program that utilizes existing fiber infrastructure to leverage resources and potentially promote greater bandwidth access to the community.”
Only some four years off, it remains to be seen if the city will be able to map out a detailed plan and execute it. The first goal is set to serve the business parks, not retail centers or other areas that may need high speed. The second goal appears to be more of a revenue-generating plan for the city, rather than a strategic approach to solving a problem.
“We have good cooperation from the developers,” said Holly Schroeder, president and CEO of the Santa Clarita Valley Economic Development Corp. “I think the developers will be a strong partner with us as they build new parks because it’s a selling point for them, as well as they lease or sell their buildings.”
Outside Expertise
As for establishing more connections throughout the region, Schroeder, whose organization is only focused on looking for solutions in the business parks, theorizes that an independent, outside expert will probably be needed to assess what is needed.
“If I go to the providers, they might give me their own answers. We need real answers, not self-serving recommendations,” Schroeder said. “I need positions for the future. Demand is only going to grow and our infrastructure has to grow as the needs grow.”
Half-funded by city and county funds and half-funded by the private sector, the SCVEDC won’t be able to tackle – let alone solve – the problem alone. When compared to the resources of the city, it has a minuscule budget and only three full time and two part-time staff members.
In the meantime, progress isn’t occurring fast enough for local business owners – and that, they say, impedes attracting new businesses offering higher paying jobs.
Combined effort
High-speed Internet infrastructure is top of mind for the SCVEDC’s executive committee, of which both the city and county of Los Angeles serve on, Schroeder said. But, the non-profit economic advocacy organization will definitely need all parties to commit to the effort if a solution is to be found.
“The EDC could lead an effort, but it can’t be the sole effort,” Schroeder agreed. “We will need action from everyone.”
However, Schroeder believes the team is committed. The next step is to find the right expertise so that it can put a plan together. It’s motivated to make Santa Clarita a premier business destination for Los Angeles County, she said. Until a region-wide solution is found, however, most business owners say they are left to fend for themselves in the third largest city in the county.
Still ‘dark’
For the most part, despite the efforts of individual business park owners and businesses, much of the business community is still in the dark so-to-speak and lacks affordable, viable options to conducting business.
“The city should take a serious look to see how they can help upgrade the area,” Kanowsky said.
In the meantime, just as it said it would a year ago, Mann Biomedical Park stepped up with private money to invest in the future because it knew in order to be an attractive place to do business, it had to offer 21st Century technology. Just recently installed, one business has already hooked up, one is very close to completion, and developer/owner Intertex itself is being connected.
“We’re paying for it as park owners. We put it in and tenants are signing up,” Donohoe said. “We’re offering it as an incentive to move to the park.”

