We believe one of the tougher decisions facing Santa Clarita Valley voters on June 7 will be the “yes” or “no” question for Measure E, the $230 million bond that would provide College of the Canyons with permanent structures for its Canyon Country campus, modernize some of its Valencia campus buildings and provide much-needed parking for the swell of students that have pushed our community college from one of the smaller in the state to one of the larger.
The primary election ballot is the third time within the past 15 years the college has come to SCV voters seeking funds to build a better college.
And voters have responded with remarkable generosity, taking the college’s hand in a partnership that has seen a rather average community college become a shining example to the rest of California for preparing students for four-year universities, for working with businesses to expand career opportunities in the community, for partnering with four-year institutions to offer bachelors’ and even post-graduate degrees without leaving the Santa Clarita Valley, and for fostering programs in much-needed career areas such as nursing.
We believe the college has been a responsible custodian of taxpayers’ funds, spending wisely and refinancing when low interest rates provide a chance to save.
There’s no arguing the first-class community college provides opportunity for Santa Clarita Valley residents young and old, as well as a boost in property values.
So what’s not to like about Measure E?
A Signal analysis of school bonds published Saturday reveals that much is hidden from voters in the process of putting bonds on the ballot. This is a statewide problem, not the fault of College of the Canyons.
We’d like to call local property owners more than partners with the college — we’d like to call them investors in it. However, the actual “investors” in school bonds are those who buy them when they’re issued.
Property owners are the cash cows — those who pay off bonds and interest without being adequately informed about how much they will ultimately fork over.
The investors are protected from loss by the payers’ obligation. Where are the protections for payers?
Even if College of the Canyons wanted to tell property owners how much they would pay for Measure E, it couldn’t do so because that amount can’t be calculated at the time a bond appears on the ballot.
Actual cost to payers depends on variables such as future interest rates; the number of years bonds are financed; the assessed valuation of property within the district at the time bonds are issued; and the projected growth rate of property values.
One COC spokesman says the cost to homeowners would likely be $529 million at a payback ratio of 2.3 to 1.
But official literature for the $230 million bond measure sent out with ballot materials puts the total taxpayer cost at $483 million, a best-case scenario. Why aren’t voters informed of the potential higher cost, not just the rosiest possible picture?
The literature also fails to inform property owners that rates can rise, as they have for Measure M, COC’s most recent bond approved by voters in 2006.
On that ballot, the highest tax rate estimate was $9.73 per $100,000 of assessed property value per year. But the current tax rate for Measure M is now $14.53 per $100,000 of assessed property value per year.
Organizers of the current “Yes on E” drive are abiding by state law in releasing ballot information, but it seems they’re not providing the full picture. And the law doesn’t make them do so.
We believe taxpayers can be forgiven if they feel a bit betrayed.
The situation came about after Proposition 13 in 1978 imposed a two-thirds requirement for school bond approval.
With assurances of transparency in bond measure spending and concern over stymied school construction, voters in 2000 approved Proposition 39, a constitutional amendment that reduced the threshold required to pass California school district bonds from a two-thirds supermajority vote to a 55 percent supermajority vote.
The lower voter approval requirement is allowed only when citizens’ oversight committees for bond fund spending are in place.
But apparently financial oversight is also needed for full transparency. State law must be changed to require more transparency in school bond ballot measure financing.
Meantime, fortified with a fuller understanding of the potential cost, voters June 7 are being asked to cast a thumbs-up or a thumbs-down vote on Measure E.
We urge them to take a step back from the cost controversy and look at the college’s contribution to the community over the years. Do voters want to see COC continue to grow, adequately serving those students eager to enroll but shuffled to waiting lists; to continue its leadership role statewide in both academic and career programs; to see the temporary campus in Canyon Country built to its full potential?
Or do voters want to see the college stall at this point in development, turning away students, freezing its burgeoning career programs in place, making do without an updated Valencia campus or a finished Canyon Country campus?
We suggest a “yes” vote on Measure E — accompanied by a caution to all Santa Clarita Valley school districts: Bond measures must be more transparent in the future or that future will see no more “yeses.”
