Many of Santa Clarita residents’ complaints about their City Council members were on full display Tuesday night at the latest council meeting.
Some audience members described council members’ behavior as “feckless,” “shameful” and even “disgusting.” However, to some it was just another typical night of closed-minded thinking and hidebound decisions.
During a period introduced as “council discussion” on the matter of a war memorial for fallen veterans proposed by a citizen for Veterans Historical Park, the fighting amongst council members was so disgraceful that the fallen dead of the Santa Clarita Valley would have questioned what their “full measure” exactly bought.
The saddest part, in our view, is that most of it could have been avoided.
For context, it’s important to know that before the “War of Words” began, the council had unanimously agreed to spend $36 million of city money, virtually with no public debate, on a new Sheriff’s Station.
Within the agreement with the county for this much-needed and long-overdue facility is a condition that could cost the city an additional $15 million should it decide, within the next 15 years, that it wants to make other arrangements for law enforcement services within the city.
Only Councilwoman Marsha McLean demurred a bit, asking if the forfeiture fee that makes this contract more of a hostage-taking than an agreement between partners could be pro-rated.
But in the end she relented with “I don’t want to do anything to make this not happen.” With no further attempts to negotiate, no further studies, no instructions from the council to staff, the deal was sealed and the city acquiesced.
The council spent 17 minutes on the Sheriff’s Station issue.
The next item up for consideration was the war memorial proposal from former Vietnam combat veteran Bill Reynolds, who most recently became this newspaper’s Director of Veterans Affairs. But his quest to have a memorial built for the fallen war veterans of the Santa Clarita Valley pre-dated his employment by a considerable amount of time.
Nearly a year ago Reynolds, at his expense and the investment of his personal time, researched the Santa Clarita Valley’s war dead and had a memorial designed that most believe is very suitable for Veterans Historical Plaza.
The proposal included an indemnification commitment to ensure the project would not be funded at taxpayers’ expense. The memorial would be built with private funds.
But Reynolds had not considered he would need to face down Councilwoman Laurene Weste and her dogged determination to retain the park, which she was instrumental in creating, just as it is.
Among her comments during the hour and a half of debate over the memorial: “You don’t deconstruct hallowed ground.”
The whole affair was reminiscent of Secretary of the Interior James G. Watt’s dissension, on many of the same grounds, over the Vietnam Veterans Memorial wall located adjacent to our National Mall in Washington, D.C.
Her arguments would have been more believable had she taken the time to listen to the many speakers who addressed the council in support of the proposed war memorial — or even better yet do what Mayor Bob Kellar did and meet at the memorial to reach a compromise.
Weste claimed she knew for a fact others were in opposition to the memorial at the plaza, saying: “I am sorry they are not here tonight to be heard.” But if a Cavs–Raptors game and some Doritos were more appealing to the opposition than attending the meeting, they should be dismissed much as the Cavaliers were.
Amid the pettiness and stubbornness on display Tuesday night, we compliment Mayor Bob Kellar and councilman TimBen Boydston not only for their attempts at leadership that evening but also for their capacity to recognize that listening is a critical part of a healthy democracy.
We suspect, however, that the memorial proposal — which was referred back to staff — is less certain to eventually be placed at Veterans Historical Plaza than the new Sheriff’s Station is to be erected at its location.
But equally uncertain is the re-election of a politician who fails to heed the words of one of our great presidents, Thomas Jefferson: “I am not an advocate for frequent changes in laws and constitutions, but laws and institutions must go hand in hand with the progress of the human mind.
“As that becomes more developed, more enlightened, as new discoveries are made, new truths discovered and manners and opinions change, with the change of circumstances, institutions must advance also to keep pace with the times.”
So to be clear: We support the Sheriff’s Station despite the troublesome $15 million forfeiture fee and only wish that some of the council members would have treated the memorial proposal with as much courteous and urgent action, especially as we all prepare for Memorial Day.
To be short-sighted and narrow-minded today in politics isn’t helpful, but being tone deaf is fatal.
