The president of the Castaic Union School District board called this week for the ouster of the Santa Clarita Valley School Trustees Association leaders as anger grows over Newhall School District’s advertising campaign to recruit new students.
“I’m appalled that the two people that are the leaders of the organization in our valley are doing everything contradictory to what this organization is built upon,” Victor Torres said at Castaic Union’s board meeting Tuesday. “It’s just appalling.”
Elected school board members from all four elementary school districts make up the Trustees Association. Suzan Solomon and Christy Smith, both members of Newhall’s school board, serve as president and vice president of the association.
“I think we need to vote Sue (Solomon) out and vote Christy (Smith) out and let them dwindle into the sunset,” Torres said.
Asked about the comments, Solomon said there will be an opportunity to choose new leadership this summer.
“The terms of office that Christy and I serve are up at the end of June, so it’s a moot point,” she said.
Solomon said a nominating committee will be elected June 3, and the committee will meet this summer and select new officers to take over in September. She indicated she would not be interested in being president of the association next year.
“I’ve served quite a few times in this position over my 17 years on the (Newhall school) board, so it’s someone else’s turn,” she said.
The Newhall School District has angered its neighboring districts with a student recruitment marketing campaign that extends outside its boundaries.
The district sent postcards to homes throughout the Santa Clarita Valley with the statement: “There’s a place for your child in the Newhall School District.”
In January, the district invited families across the Santa Clarita Valley to tour its schools. At a recent Saugus district meeting, school board members said it was unprecedented for a school to market outside its boundaries and questioned the ethics of the campaign.
Some board members with the other districts also take issue with Newhall’s repeated claims that it is the “highest-achieving elementary district in the SCV.”
A task force with two members from each district was created to address the campaign.
“The first meeting was largely unproductive when Newhall essentially would not agree to stop their advertising,” said Stacy Dobbs, a Castaic board member.
Representatives from Castaic and Saugus boycotted the next meeting, she said. Sulphur Springs and Newhall representatives came up with three points of discussion for each school district board to consider.
Dobbs said a trustee from another district followed up to ask Newhall to stop making statements that students throughout the Santa Clarita Valley are welcome at its district. She said Newhall has not responded to the request.
Solomon said she believes the discussions between school board members should remain private at this time.
Earlier this month she defended the campaign, saying Newhall is not trying to disparage any other schools in the valley.
“The purpose of the marketing campaign is to provide parents with additional options,” Solomon said. “Parents look around for schools. Anymore, we have private schools and charter schools advertising.”
Margo Minecki, spokeswoman for the Los Angeles County Office of Education, said parents who want their children to attend school in a district outside the area where they live must request an inter-district transfer from their home district.
If the home district denies the transfer, the parents may appeal to the Los Angeles County Office of Education.

