The four-year plan by the Santa Clarita Valley Sanitation District to reduce the amount of chloride that ends up in the Santa Clara River has been put on hold following a court ruling, throwing into question the district’s ability to meet the plan’s rigid timeline benchmarks.
Failure to meet those benchmarks could expose the district to state fines for not complying with the promise it made to state water regulators. The cost of any fines would ultimately be passed on to Santa Clarita Valley property owners on their property taxes.
Two members the three-member SCV Sanitation District Board met at City Hall Monday and discussed behind closed doors the lawsuit filed against the district by a group of disgruntled SCV ratepayers, called the Affordable Clean Water Alliance, and a judge’s ruling in the case.
In its suit, the alliance challenged the environmental studies used by the district to support its chloride-removal plan.
After district board members emerged from closed session, attorney Paul Beck said the district will comply with the judge’s ruling, prepare the information the judge requested and stop all work on its four-year chloride reduction plan.
Judge’s ruling
Judge James C. Chalfant wants district officials to explain in greater detail how they will protect the unarmored threespine stickleback — an endangered species of native fish.
“The judge ordered the district to do further studies and a further environmental analysis on the ‘use of reclaimed water’ portion of the project. And not to proceed with the project,” Beck said.
In his initial ruling in March, Chalfant called for more studies on the effects of recycled water on the tiny endangered fish.
When they responded to the court order in March, district officials hoped they could separate the issue of recycled water from the rest of the Environmental Impact Report for the chloride-reduction plan that was challenged by the water alliance.
That plan didn’t work.
Chalfant concluded Thursday the district acted in good faith but “took action in furtherance of the project that violated the writ by seeking project funding. Those actions could be construed as negligent disregard of the writ.”
In the end, the judge ordered the district to return “when it has certified an EIR for the project in a manner that complies with the California Environmental Quality Act.”
Two years
The chloride-reduction plan is a promise made two years ago to state water regulators by district officials that they would reduce the amount of chloride discharged into the Santa Clara River.
In October 2014, members of the Los Angeles Regional Water Quality Control Board listened to heated complaints from downstream Ventura County farmers about continued “pollution” of the river and about the Santa Clarita Valley Sanitation District’s “lack of political will” to act to reduce chloride concentration levels.
The farmers contend high levels of chloride — a component of common table salt — damages salt-sensitive crops such as strawberries and avocados.
Regional board members gave SCV sanitation officials four years to build a chloride-reducing treatment system for wastewater dumped into the Santa Clara River.
In doing so, they ordered the district to meet a rigid timeline of benchmarks set for completing each stage of the plan.
‘Don’t know’
Asked about the impacts of the judge’s ruling on the district’s four-year plan, Beck said: “We’re still considering what to do. What the impact will be, we don’t know.”
Environmental lawyer Robert P. Silverstein, attorney representing the Affordable Clean Water Alliance, said the district broke the law when it failed to follow Chalfant’s ruling in March calling for further environmental analysis.
“I have never seen a government agency so unresponsive to a court ruling as the sanitation district,” he said Monday. “There is an arrogance of power by the Sanitation District that is not acceptable.”
661-287-5527
on Twitter @jamesarthurholt

