In the early 90’s, Whittaker-Bermite, the owners of the doughnut-hole center of Santa Clarita, retained Sam Veltri and his company to get a housing development approved for the site. Their plan, dubbed Porta Bella, called for a mini-city of 10,000 or more people and, after a few revisions, the city approved it.
But, not before citizens raised concerns about the property’s toxic history.
Back in the 40’s and 50’s, the folks who then owned the property made fireworks there. People who lived in Newhall remember the almost weekly explosions from the materials used in making the skyrockets.
Then Whittaker bought the property, making Sidewinder missiles and depleted uranium bullets there. What are these bullets? According to Wikipedia, “Most military use of depleted uranium has been as 30 mm caliber ordnance, primarily … armour-piercing incendiary rounds.”
During the development approval process, Whittaker tried to downplay the significance of the site’s contaminated history. One of its attorneys even told the Santa Clarita Planning Commission, “There’s nothing there, just a few oily rags.”
After spending hundreds of millions of its own - and its insurance company's - money to clean up the soil and groundwater, one would assume that attorney would characterize differently the property’s contamination.
So, Whittaker, after spending all of this money to address a problem that, according to them, did not exist, is now suing the United States government to reimburse them for the clean-up costs.
Whittaker argues that since 90 percent of the work it did there was for the U.S. military, the U.S. should contribute to restore the location to a clean environment. Whittaker, in its lawsuit, says that the clean-up efforts are far from over, alleging that it “will continue to incur substantial costs for the indefinite future.”
In the federal court system, there are essentially three levels of courts. The first is the District Court, much like the state’s Superior Court. If you don’t like what the District Court did, you can appeal to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. If you disagree with their decision, you can ask the U. S. Supreme Court to review it.
In Whittaker’s case against USA, the District Court ruled that Whittaker was too late in bringing its claim against the government.
On June 13th, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals issued its decision, reversing the District Court, ruling that Whittaker could proceed with its case against the American government to try and force it to help pay for the remediation costs.
The 9th Circuit ruled that, “Allowing a party who has incurred substantial environmental response costs over a span of decades to recover from other potentially responsible parties serves” two goals “to incentivize both environmental cleanup efforts and negotiated settlements of liability.”
After all, the appellate court said, “Potential purchasers of abandoned or underutilized contaminated properties are often deterred from purchasing and cleaning up these properties by exposure to unbounded and uncertain liability.”
Thus, it’s back to the District Court to see if Uncle Sam has to chip in for the bill to pick up “the few oily rags.”
Carl Kanowsky of Kanowsky & Associates is an attorney in the Santa Clarita Valley. He may be reached by email at [email protected]. Mr. Kanowsky’s column represents his own views, and not necessarily those of The Signal. Nothing contained herein shall be or is intended to be construed as providing legal advice.
