In a Foothill League loaded with bats, pitching won the day.
It’s hardly a coincidence that the two teams with elite arms shared this year’s league crown. And there’s no question recent Saugus High graduate Mariah Lopez and Valencia High junior-to-be Shea O’Leary are elite.
The question lies in who had a better 2016, and people are firmly entrenched on both sides of the argument.
Some cite Lopez’s 12 strikeouts per seven innings as proof of her superiority.
Others might point to O’Leary’s minute walks per seven innings (1.44) as more impressive.
O’Leary had a 1.80 ERA, Lopez a 1.67.
O’Leary’s walks and hits per innings pitched was .966, Lopez’s 1.041.
O’Leary threw 198 2/3 innings to Lopez’s 121.
It’s hard to separate the two, and, frankly, we reserve the right not to. They are the 2016 All-Santa Clarita Valley Softball co-Players of the Year.
“Obviously, it’s a really cool honor to be All-SCV Player of the Year,” says Lopez, who is headed off to play at the University of Oklahoma after being named Foothill League Pitcher of the Year. “Especially getting to share it with Shea.”
Lopez said that while there’s no hard feelings between the two, there will always be a certain level of rivalry because of the teams they played for in high school and the Big 12 opponents (O’Leary is a University of Texas commit) they’ll join in college.
This season they took turns getting the better of each other. O’Leary struggled in the teams’ first meeting, allowing six earned runs and four home runs.
Lopez threw a complete-game three-hitter in a 6-1 win.
The tables turned the second time around as Lopez gave up 10 runs (six earned), while O’Leary shut out the Centurions in a 10-0 six-inning game.
The teams split the Foothill League crown with identical 9-1 records. It was Valencia’s first title since winning 10 straight from 2001 to 2010, and O’Leary’s maturation was at the center of it.
After struggling against Saugus and Golden Valley early in league play, the 6-foot-2-inch righty went on a tear, allowing eight hits over her next four starts in league.
“It felt awesome,” said O’Leary, who was named co-Foothill League Player of the Year along with Saugus’ Lindsay Clare. “Especially because I’m just stating to sprout and reach my full potential.”
O’Leary carried the momentum into the CIF-Southern Section Division 1 playoffs, leading Valencia to 3-0 and 6-0 wins in the first two rounds.
She was solid in the quarterfinals, too, but Valencia fell 2-1 to Norco High.
Lopez’s postseason run ended in the first round, when a fluky fifth inning led to two runs in a 2-1 loss to Edison High of Huntington Beach.
Lopez struck out 15 batters in the game to give her 32 strikeouts in her final two outings of the year.
She finished with 208 strikeouts in her senior year, a campaign that ended far better than her junior year had.
Lopez missed all but two Foothill League games in 2015 due to an elbow injury. She started pitching again that summer and came into her 2016 prep season ready to roll — which for the most part she did.
Still, she consistently says she’ll remember who she played with more than what she accomplished.
“I just hope that people can look back,” Lopez said, “and see that I tried my best and I left a good legacy at Saugus for the rest of the kids that will be attending school there, and that I got to spend the time with my sister (first baseman Makayla Lopez) and best friends.”
As far as on the field, Lopez treasures her sophomore season when she posted a .66 ERA and 170 strikeouts in 94 innings en route to a co-Foothill League crown and All-SCV co-Player of the Year award.
She’s obviously hoping her biggest softball accomplishments are ahead of her at Oklahoma, where she just may run into O’Leary again.
Then it will be up to Big 12 prognosticators to debate who’s better.


