It’s very common for businesses to sell goods and services online using a web-based contract. Some websites require customers to click “I agree” when purchasing goods and services. Others simply have a “terms of use” link at the bottom of the website that contains the contract terms.
Businesses typically consider the website’s “terms of use” and other online contract terms as enforceable agreements. But are they really enforceable? Recent California court cases have found that depending on the format, layout and language of the website, the answer may be “no”.
There are two types of online contacts frequently used by businesses. Both are listed below:
Browsewrap Agreement:
The contract terms for using the company’s website, downloading a file or purchasing a good or service are posted on the website, usually in a “terms of use” link at the bottom of the Home Page. The terms of use typically say that by continuing to access and use (“browse”) the website, the customer has agreed to the terms. The customer’s agreement is established simply by continued use of the website.
Clickwrap Agreement:
The customer has to physically do something to accept the contract terms, such as clicking on a box that states “I agree”. The contract terms must be provided in a clear manner, and not hidden within the website or in a way that doesn’t alert the customer. Clickwrap Agreements can be easier to enforce because they provide evidence the customer had actual notice of the contract terms, and agreed to them by physical action.
Suggestions for businesses to consider when creating Online Contracts:
Consider a Clickwrap” Agreement
• Consider using a Clickwrap Agreement rather than a Browsewrap Agreement. The agreement should clearly and provide all the contract terms, including any terms that may be found by clicking on a link or in related documents.
• If any terms are contained within links to separate webpages or websites, the opportunity to click on the links and review the terms prior to clicking the “I Agree” Button is critical.
• The links and information should be located above the “I Agree” Button.
• Consider a “scroll” feature that contains all contract terms, and requires customers to scroll down to the bottom before they can click on the “I Agree” Button.
• If the purchase involves online software or other products with license terms that may change periodically, the purchaser must be advised in advance, and be made aware before the terms change in the future and confirm acceptance.
• If a purchase is made on behalf of a company, the purchaser should confirm they are authorized to bind the company with the purchaser’s name and title, along with a valid email address for correspondence.
Consider a “Browsewrap” Agreement with a “Text Notice”
• If a business wants to use a Browsewrap Agreement, the website must clearly notify the customer of the terms of use or other contract terms.
• The customer must know the terms of use or other contract terms exist.
• The customer must be able to locate and review the terms on the website before proceeding.
Online agreements can be enforceable if the company’s website has the proper format, layout and language in place. Businesses should conduct a review of all website agreements and contact the Website Administrator and/or an Attorney to ensure the company’s online contracts are enforceable.
The author Erica Bristol is an Attorney, Mediator and a Business Advisor with the Small Business Development Center (SBDC) hosted by College of the Canyons (COC) serving Northern Los Angeles County – the Antelope, San Fernando, and Santa Clarita Valleys.
