The Santa Clarita Valley Sanitation District – sued over challenges to the environmental studies it used to support its four-year chloride-removal plan – has been sued again by the same local group of disgruntled Santa Clarita Valley ratepayers.
The district was forced last month by court order to go back to the drawing board for a state-approved report on the environmental impact of its plan to reduce the amount of chloride that ends up in the Santa Clara River. And it was served April 20 with another lawsuit filed by the group called the Affordable Clean Water Alliance.
The new lawsuit claims district officials failed to inform the public about the Environmental Impact Report it “augmented and modified” in an effort to comply with an earlier court order.
Specifically, it claims the district failed in its latest environmental impact report to tell Santa Clarita Valley residents about the “hazardous chemicals” planned to be used to remove brine from wastewater.
Environmental attorney Robert P. Silverstein, who filed both lawsuits on behalf of the Affordable Clean Water Alliance, said the “main aspect of the second lawsuit has to do with the safety of the brine concentration process.”
Concentrating brine and shipping it out of the area was a compromise reached after West Side residents protested injecting brine deep underground near their property in 2015.
“The safety aspect of this (brine concentration) is not addressed for the protection of the Valencia residents nearby,” he said.
Paul Prestia, division engineer for the Sanitation Districts of Los Angeles County, confirmed the ACWA’s second lawsuit challenging the plan to concentrate brine and truck it out of the area. He said a trial date for the second lawsuit is not likely until early 2017 “or possibly not until the first CEQA challenge is resolved.”
State water quality regulators have ordered the Sanitation District to reduce chloride, a naturally occurring component of common table salt, in the treated water it discharges into the Santa Clara River under the federal Clean Water Act. But the best method to do so has been a point of contention since 1989, when the state set acceptable levels of chloride in the river of 100 milligrams per liter – a level much lower than that allowed in most other parts of California.
In 2008 voters approved a ban on salt-discharging water softeners in homes and business, but in 2010 ratepayers rejected a plan to reduce chloride that could cost them a half billion dollars or more.
A less costly alternative plan was adopted in 2013, but that plan has since met with opposition.
The district was fined a quarter of a million dollars in 2011-12 and could face more fines if the plan approved in 2013 doesn’t meet strict deadlines laid out by the Los Angeles County Water Quality Control Board.
661-287-5527
on Twitter @jamesarthurholt

