“Horse whisperers” have special talents to quietly calm and train wild horses.
Through bad politics, we’ve learned that “dog whistlers” use disingenuous, manipulative words to enrage and whip up bigotry in otherwise calm and reasoned voters.
Beware the master dog whistler who now beguiles us on the national stage. Beware the dog whistler who speaks to your ears clever words designed to enrage hate against “the other.”
Beware the dog whistler who would divide our nation for his own empowerment, who destroys our national respect and honor for his own aggrandizement, and who tells us all our efforts and of those before us have come to naught and “the others” are at fault.
Yes, America has always had challenges to overcome, from struggles for independence, to civil war, to world wars, to civil rights, health rights, human rights, and through the ups and downs of capitalism.
Yet always we’ve looked to improve, to move beyond problems, and to create a better world. And we have created a great America.
Now enters the Dog Whistler, telling us we must “Make America Great Again.” He whistles the pejorative “again,” telling us we’ve lost our way.
He whistles “again,” sowing doubts that we’ve been duped and tricked and we’re losers. And the dog whistler says, “Only he alone can fix us” – that we’re defective, we’re losers, we’ve lost and we need mim to save us from ourselves.
Making America great “again” whistles to the left-behind ones, passed by progress and life and the march of justice for all.
It whistles to bigots who fear the competition of those races who were previously forced down, put down, and kept down so as not to compete. And it whistles to sexists, who want women back in the kitchen and gays back in the closet.
“Again” spoken by the master dog whistler convinces these angry ones that all is lost, that all of America is a failed.
Yet America by almost any standard is at its greatest point ever. From economic activity to stock markets to employment rates to quality of life to health care availability, to civil rights to international relations – we’ve scarcely ever been better.
Things surely didn’t look better in the Civil War when we killed 620,000 Americans. Things surely didn’t look good to the American Indians through the long march of Manifest Destiny.
We surely don’t want to go back to the days of gangsters and prohibition and tenements and rural poverty and child labor of the 1920s, followed by those tortuous years of the 1930s and early ‘40s and the Great Depression.
We were at perhaps our finest hour of honor during World War II, but our men returned to a recession and our minorities returned home to entrenched racism and bigotry.
Blacks were on backs of buses and could not purchase homes in areas redlined against them. Pollution was rampant with DDT in our food, lead in our air and rivers literally on fire. Does the dog whistler think this is the “great” that we want?
Or to the 1960s, when we ruined tens of thousands of lives on an ill-advised Vietnam war and riots filled out streets and discord our colleges and universities and children were turned against parents in a generation gap for the ages – and blacks still were forced to the streets for something resembling equal rights.
Or to any one of two Iraq wars? Or to negligence in the White House leading to the Twin Towers collapsing and the Pentagon attacked, killing 3,100 Americans?
Or to an inept Hurricane Katrina response where first responders were delayed to the cost of another 1,100 American lives. Are these the days to which the dog whistler thinks we should return?
Contrastingly, we’ve now enjoyed eight years of progress from the Great Recession. We’ve enjoyed the longest economic expansion on record, doing far, far better than peer nations.
Our cities are safer; our crime is lower by far than historic trends. Our military is funded greater than the next eight countries combined.
“Make America Great Again” is a dark, manipulative lie whistled in our ears to reactive, deep-seated bigotries that most have overcome. It has almost no basis in any rational fact.
“Make America Great Again” would be funny if it wasn’t so insulting to all those who’ve given so much over decades and centuries to make us enduringly great today.
So beware the dog whistler sounding to your worst fears rather than your best intentions. Do not be split off course by manipulated fear. There’s only forward or backward, and backward to “again” is far worse than “today” and “forward.”
Yes, America has challenges, as always. But as always, as the great nation we are, we will meet them, leaving a better, even greater America for those inheriting our work on their behalf.
Gary Horton is a Santa Clarita resident. “Full Speed to Port!” appears Wednesdays in The Signal.
