ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· signalscv.com, Wayback capture

UPDATE: Court upholds CLWA purchase of Valencia Water

The Castaic Lake Water Agency’s purchase of Valencia Water Company is legal, a California appellate court has ruled, siding with the court that reached the same decision over a year ago and denying a local environmental group’s effort to halt the sale.

The California Court of Appeal 2nd District upheld the right of the agency to acquire Valencia Water Company stock, rejecting the 2013 legal challenge by the local environmental group Santa Clarita Organization for Planning and the Environment, or SCOPE.

“The Appeals Court ruling confirms that the acquisition and ownership of the Valencia Water Company stock is legal,” Matt Stone, Castaic Lake Water Agency general manager, said Monday.

“We were glad to see that both the lower court and appellate court did agree with our understanding of the law with respect to this matter.”

The court’s decision last week affirms a 2015 trial court ruling that approved the agency’s purchase of Valencia Water Company from Newhall Land and Farming in 2012. The Court of Appeal rejected all of SCOPE’s arguments.

But the Santa Clarita Valley environmental group members remain steadfast and vowed Monday to take their fight all the way to the Supreme Court of California.

“We will be petitioning the Supreme Court to review this decision because we believe it was wrongly decided,” SCOPE spokeswoman Lynne Plambeck said Monday.

“SCOPE continues to believe that this acquisition is illegal and harms the ratepayers of Valencia Water Company by creating a monopoly that will result in an unfair rate structure and may unfairly distribute our valley’s water supply.”

Water monopoly

Critics say the purchase of Valencia Water Company stock was another step in Castaic Lake Water Agency’s plan to become the only water supplier in the Santa Clarita Valley.

The agency is a water wholesaler that provides imported water to three main water retailers in the valley and one smaller retailer. The three main retailers get about half their product from ground water supplies; the smaller retailer buys CLWA water exclusively.

But of the three once-independent retailers, Castaic Lake bought one outright and now owns the stock of a second.

Only Newhall County Water District remains, and early this year members of both the Castaic Lake and Newhall County boards of directors began talks about a merger.

Court ruling

In the Valencia Water Court of Appeal ruling, the court said California’s constitution does not prohibit Castaic Lake from acquiring the stock of a water company, nor does that ownership conflict with a provision of Castaic Lake’s formation act limiting the agency’s operation of retail water service to certain areas.

The Court of Appeal, which had 90 days to issue its opinion, issued its 33-page ruling within a week of hearing oral arguments.

“We are extremely pleased that the Court of Appeal, just like the trial court, has rejected SCOPE’s claims and affirmed what we knew all along, that CLWA’s acquisition of Valencia Water Company was legal,” CLWA President Tom Campbell said in a prepared statement.

“This was a sound water management decision by CLWA consistent with our vision to innovate and improve water management in the Santa Clarita Valley. The Court of Appeal ruling puts the community one step closer to realizing the benefits of that vision for more effective regional water management and more efficient operations,” Campbell said.

Lawsuits

According to Plambeck, who is a long-standing elected member of the Newhall County Water District board, the Castaic Lake Water Agency was created by an act in 1962 specifying: “The agency may acquire water and water rights, including, but not limited to, water from the State of California under the State Water Resources Development System, and provide, sell, and deliver that water at wholesale only.”

Plambeck stressed the word “only.”

“CLWA was not set up to take over local retailers,” she said. “The court has just ignored this statutory language in CLWA’s enabling act.”

The Newhall County Water District had filed a lawsuit similar to the one filed by SCOPE to contest the legality of the Valencia Water stocks being sold to Castaic Lake.

But Newhall County’s general manager, Steve Cole, said Monday that lawsuit “has been voluntarily stayed since January,” when merger talks with Castaic Lake were made public.

“The focus of our Board of Directors is to work corroboratively with CLWA to resolve differences and build a better way of managing our regional water resources,” Cole said.

“This could bring about positive changes to water governance, stabilized water rates, more integrated water management and greater water reliability.

“We’re confident we can achieve these goals and settle the lawsuit as part of the process,” he said.

[email protected]

661-287-5527

on Twitter @jamesarthurholt

← Back to 2016

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
155077
System
Morris section CMS (/section/…/article/… and /archives/…)
Reading copy
signalscv.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 772 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 14 (counted, not reproduced here); images 1.
Extracted by
section_cms:articlebody_span
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • url:section_36_local
  • byline:staff_marker [[address]]
  • text:valley_names [8 distinct/48 mentions: Santa Clarita, Valencia, Newhall, Castaic, Newhall Land, Castaic Lake Water, Newhall County Water, Valencia Water]
National signals
  • text:national_politics_vocab_light [2 hits]
Scores
local 9, national 1