As the 15th anniversary of the 9/11 attacks approaches, there will be all manner of remembrances, nationally and locally, to reflect on that terrible day in New York, Washington and Pennsylvania – a day that left some 3,000 dead, a day that continues to impact the nation and the world.
For those old enough to remember, it’s a touchstone day – the way Dec. 7, 1941, and Nov. 22, 1963, were to earlier generations. Everyone old enough to remember, remembers where they were on 9/11.
But after 15 years, there’s now a whole generation of youngsters and young adults who were not born or were too young to remember when those hijacked planes took down the Twin Towers in New York and crashed into the Pentagon and a field in tiny Shanksville, Pa.
Those young people have nothing to remember – so what are they being taught?
Most schools around the Santa Clarita Valley have held, or will hold, ceremonies to mark the 9/11 anniversary – but what are youngsters learning about the whys behind the formalities, the history that preceded the tragedy and the consequences that followed it?
The Signal spoke to several area educators to get a sense.
Grade-schoolers
"You have to be careful when speaking to elementary-age students – you want to approach it at a level they can understand and not instill fear," said Jon Baker, principal of the K-6 Emblem Academy in Saugus.
Baker led a National Day of Service and Remembrance ceremony with students outside the school on Friday morning, featuring local first responders and military, in uniform, and concluding with a flag-raising, a moment of silence for the fallen and the singing of “God Bless America.”
It was one of numerous such events held in Santa Clarita Valley schools on Friday to recognize first responders and the military.
“We don’t get into the details of the terrible things that happened that day,’’ Baker said. “However, they do get exposure to some of the facts. It is a day of remembrance – we never want to forget it. I want the students to understand that good things can come out of terrible situations, people helping others and demonstrating amazing acts of heroism.”
Emblem Academy’s assembly, Baker said, was his young students’ “primary source” of 9/11 education at their level.
Honoring – and emulating – such heroism and sacrifice is his students’ biggest lesson, he said.
“That’s the message we pass along to our students – what they can do as citizens to promote that type of citizenship and service,” Baker said.
High schoolers
Local high school students get a more detailed and nuanced take on the events of 9/11.
“We definitely cover it in depth,” said Robert Fisher, chairman of the social studies department at Golden Valley High School.
In previous years, he said, his high schoolers had personal memories of 9/11 – “but now we have to teach it.”
Engaging students
In his classes, Fisher said, he has “relived” the day in great detail with students, using a timeline, graphics and videos. He then opens up the class “to discuss what impact it had on the nation and why we should remember.”
“It’s gotten students to talk about why we need a strong national defense, why we need a CIA, things like that,’’ Fisher said. “We get a lot of students engaged because the events of that day still connect to what they see going on today.”
He said that while his classes around the 9/11 anniversary itself focus on the events of the day – the deaths and the heroism of the first responders – at other times in the school year he covers the roots of the ideology that created the suicide hijackers.
At Trinity Classical Academy, a Christian school in Valencia, students held a morning prayer service on Friday – and then placed 2,977 American flags in the school’s courtyard, one for each of the people who died on 9/11.
The topic of the tragedy was also on the academic agenda for later in the day.
Why we remember
Liz Caddow, who is Head of School and also teaches 12th grade honors history, said her class planned “to talk about why we remember.”
“It’s a springboard to the larger discussion of what’s happened since 9/11, to get into the response of our nation,” said Caddow. “It allows for the larger conversation about ideology and world views, and how ideologies have consequences – how certain ideologies are good, others might be evil.”
Wally Caddow, her husband and the managing director of the school, said students were also taught, “how we (in the United States) are not insulated from the rest of the world.”
“It’s a springboard to discuss the clash of world views, a political, economic and cultural discussion,” he said. “It’s an excellent opportunity to contrast how different faith groups think.”
In addition, Mrs. Caddow said, Kaeli Massetto’s sixth-grade class was to watch a video Friday “to see the imagery of what happened … as much as they can handle (at that age.)”
Lessons learned
Tiffany Desmond, a third-grade teacher at Emblem Academy, said she, too, takes an age-appropriate approach to 9/11 with her pupils.
“They learn our country was attacked … they know that the towers came down … but we focus mostly on the positive response to it – the heroes, the first responders, the military who protect our country,” she said.
“As far as the source of it, the terrorists, we didn’t focus on that. We talked about how people sometimes sacrifice their lives to keep us safe, and we talked about what you can do to make your world a better place, how you can be a good citizen.’’
Darcy Rojas, who teaches ninth and 10th graders at West Ranch High School, visited the 9/11 Memorial in New York with her family this summer and brought back a book of some 1,000 photos taken after the attacks. She has created a mural on her classroom windows using some of the pictures, for students to ponder as they pass.
She said terrorism will be discussed in detail in the second semester of her 10th-grade world history class – but that with the 9/11 anniversary at hand, she’s recently shown news clips from that day and held class discussions about what led up to the attacks.
“We talked about how people who didn’t appreciate or necessarily want American intervention in the Middle East decided they wanted to send a message that they want us to leave them alone,” Rojas said.
“We discussed how the buildings targeted were very much representations of our country – the World Trade Center for economic symbolism, the Pentagon for the military – and how the country has changed since then, just traveling by plane, how you used to be able to just go to the gate, but not anymore.”
“I wouldn’t be doing my job as a history teacher if I didn’t make (the students) aware of what happened,” she said.
(661) 287-5525

