Proposition 57 on the Nov. 8 ballot is another effort by Gov. Jerry Brown to rid the state of its inconvenient prison population by turning prisoners loose on the public.
Never mind that it claims to allow parole consideration for only non-violent felons incarcerated for property crimes.
That shell game was run on us before with AB109, the 2011 law that moved thousands of so-called non-violent, non-serious and non-sexual felons from state confinement to county lock-ups, where many were placed under county supervision – which was both overburdened and underfunded – and then prematurely released.
We then learned that courts allowed all sorts of exemptions to the terms non-serious, non-sexual and non-violent, and that serious, sexual and violent criminals were released into our communities by AB109.
Proposition 57 proposes to continue that trend – but only with the consent of voters. We urge our readers not to give that consent.
Some pundits focus on the change the measure would make to juvenile criminal proceedings – placing into the hands of judges the decision on prosecuting juveniles as adults, rather than into the hands of prosecutors, who are more likely to be familiar with the cases. But the real public hazard of this proposed constitutional amendment is that it would accelerate early release of dangerous prisoners.
Both law enforcement and prosecutors in Los Angeles County vehemently oppose Proposition 57.
“The offenses of rape by use of drugs, sexual penetration of an unconscious person, and oral copulation of an unconscious person are crimes which do not qualify as ‘violent’ under the penal code and therefore are eligible for early release under Proposition 57,” wrote George Hofstetter, president of the Association for Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs, and Michele Hanisee, president of the Association of Los Angeles Deputy District Attorneys, in a joint column opposing the ballot measure.
Child molesters and murderers also could be considered for early release if Prop 57 passes, both state.
In a separate column opposing the measure, Hofstetter points out that a parole board would determine whether convicted felons quality for early release based upon “educational or rehabilitative achievements” undefined by the ballot measure.
Boards could consider “rehabilitative achievements” as trivial as completion of a physical education class, he wrote. Parole boards have no accountability to the public.
Further, he notes, parole board decisions would not be subject to review under the measure.
California has spent a couple of short-sighted decades getting itself into the situation of too many inmates, not enough room for them all.
It’s a tough problem to solve, but we don’t believe devising flimsy excuses to release violent prisoners – and then writing those knee-jerk responses into the state’s Constitution – is the best approach.
Vote no on Proposition 57 on Nov. 8. AB109 and 2014’s voter-approved Proposition 47, which reduced many felonies to misdemeanors, have done more than enough to endanger law-abiding Californians’ lives and property.
