The fate of a man charged with three felony counts of assaulting a police officer now rests with the jury, after he and the man prosecuting him delivered closing arguments today in court, a spokesman for the Los Angeles County District Attorney’s Office said.
Acting in his own defense, Calvin Charles Lynch, 29, told a jury of eight men and four women at San Fernando Superior Court Friday to use common sense when they considered the charges against him.
He is charged with three counts of assaulting a peace officer, two counts of false imprisonment of a hostage and two counts of cruelty to a child by endangering the child’s health.
Lynch, secured at the waist and speaking to jurors from the defendant’s chair, told them deputies should have informed him on that night that he was suspected of holding his two children hostage at the time he barricaded himself inside their bedroom armed with a butcher knife.
“I should have been told I was holding my kids hostage,” he told the jury Friday in his closing statements. “I was never under the impression that my kids were held hostage.
“Did I know that I was under arrest? No. I didn’t. I thought everything was cool,” he told jurors.
Lynch said from his point of view events that unfolded the night deputies responded to a domestic violence call placed by his wife, began de-escalating when he threw the knife out of the bedroom.
Deputies, however, had already called for additional backup once Lynch held the children hostage in a bedroom.
Deputy District Attorney Garrett Dameron who handles cases for the DA’s Crimes Against Police Officers unit revisited the testimony of eight deputies who painted a picture of escalating violence the night of the arrest.
Once deputies with the Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff’s Station determined they were able to lawfully arrest Lynch, he was legally obliged to comply with deputies’ orders and surrender.
What unfolded the night of Jan. 21, 2016, however, was a violent altercation between Lynch and deputies which left one deputy with head injuries.
Two exhibit photographs shown to the jury included a close up of deep gashes to the head of Deputy Chris Germansen and a hospital photo of the deputy heavily bandaged and in a neck brace.
“Once deputies could make a lawful detainment, the defendant was obliged to submit,” Dameron told the jury in his closing argument. “They are under no obligation to say ‘we’re arresting you for this or that.’”
Dameron recapped the testimony given during Lynch’s week-long trial by Deputy Ruth Craft telling Lynch repeatedly to send his six-year-old son and three-year-old daughter out of the bedroom where he remained armed with a knife.
In addressing the specific charge against Lynch of false imprisonment of a hostage, Dameron outlined for the jury why Lynch was culpable.
“The defendant said he would never hurt the children and did not threaten the children,” he said. “But, what he doesn’t understand is that what he did do - which makes him liable - is victimizing his own children by purposely putting them in harm’s way.”
The jury began deliberating Friday afternoon and was expected to resume Monday morning.
661-287-5527
on Twitter @jamesarthurholt

