ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Don't Take Me Seriously

Patience and dog-pointing

Dumb, stubborn or just messing with you, dogs seriously love to test your patience

So, I'm out in the backyard recently, playing fetch with the Lhasa Apso that I inherited by default. (I won't go into details.) And, by "playing fetch," I mean the dog did the fetching, not me.

He was inclined to think the game was played the other way around, of course, and the "learning" here took some time.

I am so proud of my little victory.

Sidebar: Now dog lovers and dog trainers, and people who have had their faces surgically altered to appear like dogs, please do not call or e-mail to explain to me how smart dogs are and how easily they learn when presented with the proper training.

Proper training takes patience. I generally have none.

I don't like chess or checkers or card games or about anything else that can't be done while moving large muscles. (And, yes, I work at a computer all day - go figure.)

Should someone like me even have a dog? The point is moot. I have him and he owes me back rent. He is going nowhere.

Back to the story: So, I'm smugly enjoying our little game of fetch - which usually lasts about five tosses before one of us gets bored and goes for a beer.

Without even trying to fool him, I accidentally toss the toy one way while he is looking the other - and now the age-old game of "Where is it?" begins.

The dog scurries this way and that, somehow unable to see the brightly colored toy resting on the green lawn as he passes within five feet of it.

"Is he messing with me?" I wonder.

I point at the toy.

He looks at me hopefully.

I enthusiastically say, "There it is!" while grandly sweeping my arm so that the extended finger points right at the toy.

He goes the other way.

"No, no, here it is!" And I offer another exaggerated point.

He runs somewhere near the toy and I am encouraged.

"Right here, boy!" I say, as I step toward the toy, pointing.

He gets excited... and runs right by me, to go the other way.

We go through this maybe five times, until I am practically bending over the toy, pointing at it.

Then he discovers the toy like I had nothing to do with the find.

I go inside for a beer.

Now I have been in this position with numerous dogs over my lifetime and I have come to believe that they simply can't figure out that a pointing arm and finger mean "go in that direction."

(Admit it. You have most likely been there, too.)

Sure I've seen hunting dogs follow hand gestures on TV, but we all know they are special robot dogs that have been programmed by Japanese scientists. And there is probably someone controlling them by remote, anyway. Right?

So, imagine my chagrin when I go inside and Google "dogs and pointing" and one of the first things I find is an MSNBC article that states: "Dogs possess a two-year-old child's capacity to understand human pointing gestures, with dogs requiring next to zero learning time to figure out the visual communication, according to two recent studies."

"Next to zero learning time, my ____," I grumble.

Now it all becomes ever-so clear. All those dogs, for all those years - they fully understood the pointing and they were just messing with my head!

"That tears it," I say.

There is no way to go back and win this battle of wills with my previous dogs, no way to wash away the shame.

"I'll get them in the afterlife," I vow. "But the disgrace stops here." No longer will the midnight barking chain deride me as a rube.

So, with the tune from "The Good, the Bad and the Ugly" whistling and wah, wah, wahing in my head, I step out into the backyard to win this battle, to get one for the bipeds.

The dog wears a sly grin now, which I used to take as friendly. He thinks he's going to get the best of me one more time. I give him two fetches, then, this time on purpose, fake him out and toss the toy in the direction he is not looking.

And we're off.

I point. He plays dumb.

I point and encourage. He runs around aimlessly.

I step closer to the "lost" toy and point. He stops to mark a tree.

I wash the tree off, just to show him who is boss, and he marks another tree.

I reach toward the toy, faking like I will pick it up - and I see his sadistic eyes follow me gleefully. Ah ha!

But I pick up a leaf instead.

He is visibly shaken.

Now he's wondering if I'm that dumb or just messing with him .

A half hour passes of pointing and wrong-waying, and both of us are gassed. But he has had the worst of it. The "fun" of his little game has long-since run dry.

He stops down for a beer, obviously depressed.

I take one in victory.

You see, even though I haven't gotten him to follow the pointing, when I analyze it, I realize he's the rube. Yes, I'm dancing around, waving my arms and exclaiming, "Right there boy! Right there!" like a happy maniac. But the dog is running back and forth across the yard, working himself to a frazzle just to make fun of me.

Some pranks are not worth the effort.

I can see he's realized it, too.

We share a grin.

Mutual respect at last.

← Back to 2009

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
18738
System
/news/article/ pages
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 933 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
news_article:resizeabletext
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • byline:staff_marker [Editor; Escape Editor]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 3, national 0