It doesn’t matter where you are, a robo-call can find you.
“We can access cell phone numbers if voters provide them on their registration affidavits,” said Frank Adams, president of The Greensburgh Group, a political strategy company which conducted robo-calls for a local school board candidate. “However, answering machines and voice mail are the primary targets of robo-calls, so people can listen to the messages when and if they choose.”
The wide reach of “robo-calls” makes the tactic the most effective way to get the candidate’s message to a large audience quickly, said Bob Haueter, a local Republican campaign strategist, who managed the 2008 re-election bid of Congressman Howard “Buck” McKeon.
“It’s a great tool to reach out and talk to your voters,” he said. “You can target specific voters.
No matter how far the reach of robo-calls, political strategists, campaign managers and the politicians aren’t convinced that robo-calls are a magic bullet.
“The best possible manner for a candidate to communicate with a voter is to knock on doors. The next best tactic is direct mail,” Haueter said. “Every step away from an interaction by a real person with the voter you lose something.”
Robo-calls are automated campaign calls used to get a candidate’s message to the voters, said Scott Wilk, a Santa Clarita Valley campaign strategist. The tactic is usually used to excite a candidate’s base voters and push the people to the polls. But robo-calls have an uglier side. Politicians often send the automated messages out with marching orders to attack the rival candidate.
And an attack-laced robo-call can quickly devolve into candidates trading telephonic attack messages and battling each other on the phone lines, Wilk said.
“If you get hit the last weekend you have no chance to respond through direct mail,” he said. “With a robo-call you can respond to a charge the same day.”
Haueter also lauded the speed with which a campaign can react to a robo-call.
“You can pull demographic information for the robo-call like you do with direct mail, but it’s quicker,” he said.
It could take four days to issue a similar response by direct mail, Wilk said.
Messina’s own use of robo-calls came under scrutiny last week. He hired The Greensburgh Group, which placed two robo-calls for the candidate in October. The second call, which accused Hart District candidate Suzan Solomon of falsely claiming she had received key Republican endorsements, sparked a controversy. Messina’s accusations proved untrue, but the robo-calls were already underway. “Due to a computer error, the calls started anyway,” Adams said. “Joe called me that afternoon to say that the calls were going out and need to be stopped.”
Adams put the brakes on the calls, but not until after some Santa Clarita Valley residents had already heard the message.
“By this time of course, several 100 messages had already gone out,” he said. “Joe’s campaign was not billed for the calls, since they went out without final approval.”
The message sent by Messina also claimed the local Republican Party backed the robo-calls blasting Solomon. Haueter said local Republicans didn’t endorse the robo-call and Messina’s mistake put a black eye on the local party, Haueter said.
“You can’t undo that damage,” he said.
Messina’s robo-call prompted Robert Arkow, founder of Californians Against Telephone Solicitation, to file a complaint with the California Public Utilities Commission.
Adams said the political in nature robo-calls don’t fall under the same laws as commercial messages many California have fought to stop.
“Under Federal Law political campaign messages are protected free speech and therefore not governed by the same laws as commercial messages,” he said.
The immediacy of robo-calls represents a double-edged sword for many political advisors.
“That’s the thing if someone wants to record a robo-call, it can be done in an afternoon and be out that evening,” Haueter said.
But with such a short turnaround time invariably there can be mistakes.
“Lots of time people send out robo-calls without disclaiming them,” Haueter said.
The disclaimer tells people who the message is from. Without a disclaimer, candidates can be blamed for sending messages that are actually produced by other political groups, he said.
While robo-calls have been used in local elections and in swing states during national elections, many of the local politicians have not used the tactic.
Both McKeon and Assemblyman Cameron Smyth passed on robo-calls in 2008. Smyth didn’t dismiss the tactic, but said he would rather wear out shoe leather knocking on doors or using actual people.
“I prefer to have volunteers make calls,” he said.
