A local parent is challenging the Hart district over two books assigned in an honors English class at Saugus High School, saying the books’ vulgar language and sexual accounts are inappropriate for high school students.
The William S. Hart Union High School District has responded by forming a committee to analyze the books and make a recommendation.
Laura Riddle said her 14-year-old Saugus student expressed concerns about “The Glass Castle,” which was required summer reading for the honors English program.
“The Glass Castle” is a 2005 memoir by Jeannette Walls that chronicles Walls’ harsh childhood and family life.
The book includes profanity, criticisms of Christianity and accounts of sexual abuse and prostitution.
Riddle is also concerned about “The Bean Trees,” another book assigned in the honors English class.
“The Bean Trees” is a 1988 novel by Barbara Kingsolver that includes sexual scenes and vulgar language.
“I just felt that those things were not in place at school,” Riddle said.
“I think we have to remember that (students are) not adults and that we have to be very careful with what we’re assigning them. They’re still forming opinions.”
While both books are approved by the district, Saugus High School Assistant Principal Martha Spansel said students have the option of alternative assignments that still meet objectives and teaching goals.
A challenge
Riddle’s concerns have led her to file formal challenges with the Hart district.
Since finding out about the two books, Riddle said she’s talked to other Hart district parents and has gathered a total of seven formal challenges to “The Glass Castle” and four to the “The Bean Trees.”
“I really hope the district will look more carefully at the books,” Riddle said.
The formal challenge, which is rare for the Hart district, requires it to form a committee made up of an administrator, parent, teacher, department chair and librarian to formulate a report on the book and how appropriate it is for a school setting, Saugus High School Principal Bill Bolde said.
The report should be ready at the end of November, said David LeBarron, the Hart district’s director of curriculum.
Riddle also wants parents to be more informed about what students are reading.
“There should be a letter sent home,” she said. “I think it should be up front.”
Spansel, a former English teacher, said a class’s reading materials are listed on the course syllabus.
Honors students meet with teachers to receive course information ahead of time as well as contact information for teachers.
“You want to expose the kids to as much as possible,” whether it’s nonfiction, memoirs or autobiographies, Spansel said.
