Santa Clarita Valley Independent Minutemen leader Roger Gitlin says proposed immigration reform could ruin the country and the economy - and he's mad enough about it to help organize a rally this weekend.
"Mexico can't export its poverty to the U.S.," Gitlin said, referring to undocumented workers. "I love this country. ... In a short period of time it could be unrecognizable."
However, immigration experts said Gitlin and others are using inaccurate statistics and information to argue their points, and controversial Minutemen groups' misinformation campaigns hurt hopes for rational debate about the complex issue.
The rally, set for Saturday at the intersection of Valencia Boulevard and Magic Mountain Parkway in Valencia, is in protest of proposed federal legislation that would allow undocumented workers to register with the Department of Labor and possibly set up a path for citizenship.
The Minutemen are opposed to any government program that provides a path to citizenship for undocumented immigrant workers, said Gitlin, a teacher at Camp Kenyon Scudder, a juvenile detention center in Saugus. Undocumented immigrants tend to be poor and reliant on government aid, he said.
"The people who come here and wave Mexican or Colombian flags are not interested in citizenship," Gitlin said. "People from poverty come here for economic salvation, not to become citizens. ... People that don't have a means to support themselves should go back to their own country."
The local Minutemen chapter is one of several throughout the nation. Members often patrol border areas and try to "round up" people crossing the border, said Heidi Beirich, director of research for the Southern Poverty Law Center, which tracks hate groups.
The SPLC has not classified Minutemen as hate groups, but "extreme nativist" organizations. Such groups target individual immigrants, rather than merely immigration policy, Beirich said.
Linda Paine, a member of the Santa Clarita Tea Party, said the Minutemen aren't hateful, but misunderstood.
"Americans should be able to say ‘no' to illegal immigration without being called a racist," Paine said.
Tea Party members and Antelope Valley Minutemen will be participating in the rally as well.
Reform debate
There is a general consensus among conservatives and liberals that there needs to be some form of immigration reform, said Manuel Pastor, co-director of the USC Center for the Study of Immigrant Integration.
However, groups like the Minutemen are spreading false and grossly exaggerated information and hurting the discussion, he said.
"The heat on this debate is stronger than the light," Pastor said. "The corrosive tone of the debate makes it difficult to come up with rational solutions.
"Minutemen contribute to flaming this debate," he said.
Jody Vallejo, an assistant professor of sociology at USC, said information the Minutemen use is inaccurate.
Widely accepted figures show there are about 12 million undocumented immigrants living in the U.S. - about 7 million are laborers.
Gitlin said he believes there are between 25 to 30 million undocumented immigrants in the United States, citing the Pew Hispanic Center's research. However, according to numerous Pew reports, about 11.9 million undocumented immigrants are in the United States.
Pastor co-authored an academic report concluding that by legalizing undocumented workers, California could see a $16 billion boost to its economy.
"Minutemen probably raise legitimate concerns about border security," Pastor said, "but it's hard to have a rational debate (on immigration)."
Labor unions and business owners don't want to be undercut by cheaper, undocumented labor and immigrants who want to become legal citizens, he said.
About 200 people participated in the last Minutemen rally held in Valencia in 2008, according to previous Signal reports.
Gitlin said amnesty for undocumented workers would "drain" California's economy because immigrant workers tend to be poor and dependent on government aid.

