ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

The Signal Editorial Board

Our View: June Ballot Measures - The good and the bad

The June 8 primary election is fast approaching, and the ballot includes several statewide initiatives. Here is our take on the five propositions.

Proposition 13

Property tax assessment/seismic retrofitting:

Like its namesake of three decades ago, this year's Proposition 13 impacts property taxes. Unlike the old one, this measure is noncontroversial.

Under current law, your property isn't reassessed if you make earthquake upgrades - unless your home or office building happens to be made of brick or cement block. In that case, you're reassessed - and taxed at a higher rate - after 15 years.

Proposition 13 diffuses the 15-year time bomb and exempts all property from reassessment for seismic improvements, regardless of construction materials.

We think taxes shouldn't be imposed on seismic improvements whose sole purpose is saving lives and property. Vote "yes" on Proposition 13.

Proposition 14

Right to participate in primary elections:

Sacramento is broken because it's full of far-left and far-right politicians who can't agree on anything.

Look at the gubernatorial race. In left field is former Gov. Moonbeam Jerry Brown.

On the right, we have a race that has devolved into contest to see who wins the title of Most Extreme Conservative.

And stuck in the middle are growing legions of independent ("decline to state") voters who are banned under the current system from voting for partisan primary offices - even though they may well represent the moderating influence needed to get California out of its extremist rut.

When these folks go to the polls in November, it's like Goldilocks with only two bears: They don't want the porridge that's too cold, they don't want the porridge that's too hot and there is no bowl of porridge that's just right - because it got thrown out in the primary.

Proposition 14 would reshape California's electoral system.

Under Proposition 14, all candidates would appear on a single primary election ballot. The top-two vote-getters, regardless of party, would advance to a November runoff.

Come November, you might see a Republican and a Democrat on the ballot, or you might see two Democrats (which makes sense in a strongly Democratic community) or you might see two Republicans (which makes sense in a strongly Republican community).

If all voters could cast ballots in the critical June primaries, perhaps we would see candidates in the November general election who are more middle-of-the-road and representative of all voters, rather than a bunch of party hacks who won't play nice and can't get the state's business done.

Plus, we'd be more likely to see the candidates for whom they really are. No more "I'm farthest left/right" in the primary game, followed by promises of "I'll represent everyone" in the general.

Proposition 14 is the best chance we've got to rid our Legislature and congressional delegation of extremist do-nothings and replace them with thoughtful people who can communicate with each other and fix the government's mess.

Vote "yes" on Proposition 14.

Proposition 15

California Fair Elections Act:

California voters were wise to ban the use of public funds to finance political campaigns.

There are so many more important and worthy places to spend your tax money - schools, law enforcement and welfare, to name a few. Heck, we'd rather fund bridges to nowhere than a politician's campaign.

Proposition 15 is a sheep in wolf's clothing. It says it will raise lobbyists' fees to $350 per year and give the money to politicians who demonstrate broad support.

There are two problems with that claim.

First, we're all for squeezing dollars out of lobbyists, but $350 per year isn't going to cut it. Proposition 15 gives up to $5 million to each candidate - and it says that if the lobbyist fees won't cover it, which they won't, the Legislature can throw your tax money into the pot.

Given the financial squeeze on citizens today, milking them for money to run political campaigns doesn't seem a great idea.

Second, the notion of "broad support" is specious. Under Proposition 15, any Republican or Democrat who can raise five bucks from each of 7,500 people - only 3,750 people for smaller party candidates - is entitled to $5 million in state dollars.

Any political yahoo worth his salt has 7,500 Facebook fans alone. The "broad support" requirement is meaningless. There is no telling how many candidates would be entitled to $5 million each.

Proposition 15 is a test case. It applies only to candidates for secretary of state. If it flies, the Legislature will be back with another measure - this one asking you to finance their own campaigns.

Don't believe it? The Legislature put Proposition 15 on the ballot.

Vote "no" on Proposition 15.

Proposition 16

Local public electricity providers.

Pacific Gas & Electric wants a power monopoly in northern California. That's why PG&E spent millions to put Proposition 16 on the ballot. PG&E will make billions.

Don't be deceived by glossy mailers and radio ads telling you to "preserve your right to vote," or some-such nonsense, before a municipality can provide or expand electrical service.

Proposition 16 would stifle the competition by requiring a two-thirds vote before a government agency (such as the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power) can start providing electrical service or expand its current service area.

Under existing state law, only a majority vote is required to start providing service.

We believe in preserving your right to vote - and letting the majority rule.

Getting two-thirds of voters to agree that the sky is blue is difficult enough. Just wait and see what happens when the big power companies dump scads of money into local elections if they only need to sway 33.4 percent of the voters to stop a new energy project.

Proposition 16 discourages the development of new power sources and eliminates future competition for PG&E so it and the other big power companies can raise consumer rates.

Vote "no" on Proposition 16.

Proposition 17

Auto insurance:

Mercury Insurance Co. put Proposition 17 on the ballot for a reason.

You can guess the reason.

Proposition 17 wipes out part of pro-consumer Proposition 103, which eliminated redlining and keeps your auto-insurance rates from going through the roof.

There are several ways auto-insurance rates are determined. One factor is continuous coverage. Insurance companies can choose to give a discount to customers who have been with them a long time.

Proposition 17 allows insurers to give a continuous-coverage discount to people who switch from other insurance companies.

Sounds nice, doesn't it?

The trouble is: Proposition 17 allows insurance companies to penalize drivers whose insurance has lapsed for 90 days or more, even if the lapse was with another insurance company. They can't currently do that.

If you stop driving and let your insurance lapse - say, because you went off to Iraq or Afghanistan to fight for our country for a few years - and you want to start driving again when you return home, you're out of luck. Under Proposition 17, your auto-insurance rates could go up as much as $1,000 per year.

As former California Insurance Commissioners John Garamendi and John Van De Kamp said in their ballot argument against Proposition 17: "When was the last time an insurance company put something on the ballot to lower your rates?

"Never."

Vote "no" on Proposition 17.

← Back to 2010

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
28991
System
Morris section CMS (/section/…/article/… and /archives/…)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 1,216 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 10 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
section_cms:articlebody_span
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • url:section_32_local
National signals
  • text:national_politics_vocab_light [2 hits]
Scores
local 3, national 1