The proposed annexation of unincorporated neighborhoods west of Interstate 5 has driven a wedge between members of two town councils that advise Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich and the city of Santa Clarita.
The West Ranch Town Council sent a letter to the Local Agency Formation Commission last week opposing the proposed annexation of Hasley Hills, Live Oak and North Bluff neighborhoods as well as the Valencia Commerce Center.
LAFCO is a state body that oversees annexations and other municipal development issues.
The letter was sent about a month after members of the Castaic Area Town Council sent a similar letter to LAFCO, claiming the act would "annex the heart out of a long-established community."
Both letters level strong criticism against the city for allegedly pursuing the annexation, although Santa Clarita officials note that residents of the neighborhoods initiated the annexations on their own.
Sixty-one percent want to annex
"(City officials) want to take the most wealthy areas to benefit themselves, and that is fundamentally wrong," said Ron Mechsner, president of the West Ranch Town Council. "They show no respect for the residents of the west side."
Santa Clarita officials said there is nothing malicious about the proposed annexation. Rather, they're acting on a mandate from the people in the communities who want to be annexed.
"The voters in the area of this proposed annexation overwhelmingly stated their desire to annex into the city of Santa Clarita," said Deputy City Manager Darren Hernandez.
In 2007, a little more than 1,000 property owners from the Live Oak, North Bluff and Hasley Hills neighborhoods signed a petition in support of joining Santa Clarita. Currently, the communities of Stevenson Ranch, Westridge and Castaic are part of unincorporated Los Angeles County.
On Nov. 3, 2009, Castaic and other West Side community voters were asked whether they wanted to remain in the county unincorporated area, join the city of Santa Clarita or form their own city.
Of the 485 votes cast in the two Castaic precincts comprising the Hasley Hills annexation area, 61 percent said they wanted to become part of the city.
Self-determination
"Residents living in our unincorporated areas must be given an opportunity to determine their future," Hernandez said. "And the will of the people most impacted by any change in governments should be respected."
Mechsner said the voter turnout was too low to determine if West Side communities want to annex. He said a few thousand voters shouldn't determine what happens to a community made up of tens of thousands of residents.
Of the more than 22,357 registered voters in the area, 3,702 voted, said Rosalind Wayman, Antonovich's field deputy for the Santa Clarita Valley.
"The overall conclusion is that there wasn't a strong showing one way or the other," Wayman said of the November advisory vote. "This has been going on a long, long, time. The communities have been consistently opposed to an annexation that splits their community."
The town councils are elected advisory boards intended to be the "eyes and ears of the community" for Antonovich, said Tony Bell, Antonovich spokesman. However, their power is limited to providing advice to the supervisor.
Castaic and West Ranch make up two of the 18 councils in the supervisor's district.
The Castaic Area Town Council represents Castaic and Val Verde. The West Ranch Town Council represents Stevenson Ranch, Southern Oaks, Sunset Pointe and Westridge.
Lengthy process
Even if it meets no impediments, the annexation process is far from a done deal.
County and city officials need to come to terms on a property-tax-sharing agreement before LAFCO can consider any action.
The first meeting to discuss terms of an agreement was held in April. Another meeting hasn't been scheduled, Hernandez said.
Officials from LAFCO could not be reached for comment Friday.
Hernandez said he would not comment on the tone of the two letters the town councils sent to LAFCO, but he said he hoped the negotiations would be respectful.
"As community leaders, we should be looking for ways to take the high road and to respectfully agree to disagree," Hernandez said.
"‘Respectfully' is the operative word."
