Who's to blame for the proposed sewer rate hike? Most local residents are peeved, and fingers are pointing in all directions.
Santa Clarita Valley residents could pay 50 percent more for their sewer bills in four years if the Sanitation District's proposed rate increases pass. About half the hefty increase would go toward building a salt-removal system for discharged local water.
However, area residents have already made sacrifices to remove the chemical chloride from the water - namely, by removing in-home water softeners that have salt byproducts.
Salt limits for discharged water are set low because studies show they may at some levels be dangerous to crops like avocados and strawberries, which are grown downstream from Santa Clarita in Ventura County's Santa Clara River Valley.
All told, three governmental agencies and innumerable interests have had their hand in the murky issue of salty water discharge into the Santa Clara River.
Rate hike on the table
The Santa Clarita Valley Sanitation District has proposed a 50-percent service charge rate hike for wastewater treatment for each property owner in the area. That's $24.67 per month after the service charge rate increases are phased in over four years. The current rate is $16.58.
The current rate is lower than that of other cities in Los Angeles County, and Sanitation District board members cheer the community's effort to keep costs down by taking out their own water softeners in 2008.
Sanitation District officials say the move saved $70 million, but didn't cancel out the need for a $210 million salt-removal treatment system.
How much salt is too much?
The treatment system is needed to bring Santa Clarita Valley wastewater's salt levels down to the state limit of 117 milligrams per liter. The district checks the water at the county line before it penetrates Ventura County's farmlands.
The original limit was 100 milligrams per liter, but the state Water Quality Control Board acquiesced to a higher limit since the Santa Clarita Valley Sanitation District had a detailed plan to wrestle salt out of the water - from homes to the wastewater treatment facility.
But who set the limit and how? A task force formed in 2005, made up of members of the agricultural and scientific communities, read hundreds of studies and based its decision on the information gleaned from them.
Santa Clarita Mayor Laurene Weste wants to know what communities that also feed into the Santa Clara River - Fillmore, for example - are doing to lower their salt output.
Weste sits on the Sanitation District board along with Santa Clarita Councilwoman Marsha McLean and a Los Angeles County supervisor.
Who's to blame?
"Who is the enemy?" Councilwoman Laurie Ender asked Sanitation District Executive Director Steve Maguin during the council's regular meeting last Tuesday.
Maguin replied simply that the matter needed to be taken up with the California Legislature or the U.S. Congress. Congress enacted the Clean Water Act and its amendments in the 1970s. The California Legislature later decided how to administer the act.
California's answer was the State Water Resources Control Board. Nine regional boards answer to the state water board. The local regional board is the Los Angeles Regional Water Quality Control Board. Members of both the state and local water boards are appointed by the governor.
The Sanitation District must follow the mandates of the regional water board or face stiff state fines.
While no one wants to get taxed over Ventura County's avocado and strawberry crops, Santa Clarita Councilman Frank Ferry said, the city needs to be careful how it fights the rate hike.
"The last thing I think we want to do is not go through this process," Ferry said. Biting the regional water board's hand could mean the city faces a stricter salt maximum, he said.
Weste said if the state allowed for drought relief - for Santa Clarita Valley's water to be a little saltier than the limit during drought years, when water from both the State Water Project and from the ground tends to be saltier - the area would be fine. But the state water boards are not allowing for that.
What's the plan?
To meet the salt standards, the Sanitation District needs money. And that money comes from the pocketbooks of Santa Clarita Valley property owners.
The $210 million derived from rate hikes would pay for a small reverse osmosis system to remove salt from one of the two wastewater treatment plants as well as a salt management system along the river, Maguin said.
If the compliance plan wasn't in place and residents had kept their salt-discharging water softeners, the Sanitation District would be
looking at building a desalination plant that could handle the entire capacity of the area's two wastewater treatment plants, or 20 million gallons each day. That would have cost more than $500 million.
As it stands, the $210 million desalination plant and salt management system would treat 3 million gallons daily.
The Sanitation District board had hoped that having residents remove their water softeners would bring the river's salt levels to the 117 milligrams per liter threshold.
Since that hasn't done the trick, the second phase of the plan is now falling into place.
Going forward
Santa Clarita Valley Sanitation District board members Weste, McLean and Los Angeles County Supervisor Michael Antonovich - sitting in for board Chairwoman Gloria Molina - plan to meet in closed session at 5:30 p.m. Wednesday to discuss any legal recourses available to them, including shirking the sewer rate increases that Sanitation District staff members have suggested.
A special meeting that will be open to the public will take place following the closed session at 6:30 p.m., John Gulledge said. Gulledge is financial planning department head for the Los Angeles County Sanitation Districts.
One option to get out of building the pricey treatment system is to get half or more of the property owners in the Santa Clarita Valley to oppose the rate increase in writing.
This would leave the Sanitation District saddled with the cost of building the treatment plants but with no way to pay for it, Gulledge said.
The Sanitation District board could go with the proposed rates, another rate, or no rate increase - but the district would still have to build the treatment plants.
There are legal options, too, and these will be discussed at length during the closed session meeting Wednesday.
