Although the issue was billed as a complex one, the audience at the Santa Clarita Valley public forum on illegal immigration by and large offered up a simple solution: Get illegal immigrants out of America.
“It’s hard to give respect to someone who’s breaking the law,” Dan Nordenstrom said. “We have to stand very strong right now.”
Attorney Arek Nizamian said he knew how complicated immigration law was.
“I’m sorry that the (Santa Clarita) City Council even has to be here,” he said. “This is federal law. (The U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement) should be responsible for proactively enforcing that.”
The federal agency was invited to participate in the Santa Clarita city-sponsored forum but declined.
Nizamian said sheriff’s deputies couldn’t and shouldn’t be responsible for enforcing the laws. The onus should be on employers to ensure they don’t hire illegal immigrants, he said.
“It’s beyond (the Sheriff’s Department’s) scope. To scope out brown-skinned people to find out their immigration status is unrealistic,” he said.
After hearing about the community’s frustration with illegal immigration at the Monday night forum, Santa Clarita City Council members tossed around ideas about what the city might do to dampen the effects of illegal immigration.
The discussion followed an expert panel that included sheriff’s officials and a UCLA law professor telling the audience that immigration is a complex issue.
UCLA Law Professor Judy London gave a brief history of immigration law in the United States.
“There are people who say, ‘Why don’t these people leave and wait in line” to return legally, London said. “If they leave, they’ll be barred from returning for 10 years.”
London, who has taught and practiced immigration law for 20 years, said ongoing efforts to fix the illegal-immigration problem have focused on one of two solutions: creating a path to citizenship for people here illegally, and stopping the problem altogether.
The problem politically, London said, was that people who focus on border security don’t want to compromise by providing citizenship for the millions of illegal immigrants already here.
London’s comments were not well-received.
“You said you were an immigrant attorney — I bet you doggone don’t have ‘illegal’ in your title,” Richard Stefani said. “You are aiding and abetting criminals. You should be indicted, prosecuted and sent to jail. They are trespassing.”
One woman said a family member had been struck by a vehicle driven by an illegal immigrant, and her son was beaten by suspected illegal immigrants. She said she saw someone she suspected of being in the country illegally parking in a handicapped space without the proper permits.
At one point, Santa Clarita Mayor Laurene Weste warned members of the impassioned crowd that if they continued to cheer, she would end the meeting.
But audience members couldn’t contain themselves after one man spoke: Councilman Bob Kellar, whose remarks against illegal immigration at a January rally drew national attention.
Kellar scoffed at the meeting’s agenda language, which called the forum a “special immigration-education meeting.”
“We’re here to talk about illegals!” Kellar said, adding that he was disgusted at every level of government for its lack of action on illegal immigration, which has taxed agencies for untold billions of dollars.
“If they were so responsible, we would not have had this meeting,” Kellar said. “And you have to be politically correct. It’s not about what you need as a citizen. If you say anything, (people respond with) ‘What a racist you are!’”
“We have to be careful about their constitutional rights. What constitutional rights? They’re illegals!”
Ideas proposed during the forum included increased use of E-Verify, the federal Internet program aimed at halting illegal immigrants from working. Other ideas proposed included declaring Santa Clarita a nonsanctuary city and monitoring the progress of a Redondo Beach lawsuit based on that city’s recently passed law making it illegal to be or to hire a day laborer.
E-Verify is a federal program for businesses that verifies an employee’s legal status in the United States. Weste suggested use of E-Verify become a standard practice at City Hall, so that all the city’s contractors are employing legal workers.
“Sanctuary cities” include Los Angeles and San Diego, where leaders have adopted ordinances to protect illegal immigrants, like banning employees including police officers from asking people about their immigration status. Kellar suggested declaring Santa Clarita a “nonsanctuary city.”
Santa Clarita officials are keeping a close eye on Redondo Beach. A day laborers group there won a lawsuit that challenged the city’s ordinance effectively banning such workers.
The city won its appeal earlier this month, but it could face a peer review by the end of the year.
Weste emphasized writing letters to Congress voicing concern, since the federal government is tasked with addressing illegal immigration.
“I just want to make sure we become part of the solution and not part of the problem,” Weste said. “It didn’t take overnight to create the problem, and it won’t come apart overnight.”
