The creation of a Castaic high school has been debated at length in recent months.
How much should be spent on it? Where should its prospective students go until then?
When the conversation shifts to sports, the question becomes simple.
How will it impact Foothill League athletics?
“It could create some parity,” says Valencia High School athletic director Brian Stiman, “but I think parity is already existing since Golden Valley, West Ranch and Valencia opened.”
Indeed, prep sports in the Santa Clarita Valley have seemingly leveled since those three high schools opened over the past 16 years.
West Ranch athletic director Dody Garcia, who has been around local athletics for nearly four decades, has the same impression about a Castaic high school as Stiman.
“I’ve seen the transition with each high school, been on both ends as a coach,” she says. “What I really mean is the athletes will now be shared.”
Ultimately, a Castaic high school will likely even the overall playing field by taking kids away from other schools — especially Valencia and West Ranch.
Part of the need for a Castaic high school is the overflow of kids from the area being sent to Valencia and West Ranch. But as any coach will admit, bigger turnout will foster competition and improve a team, no matter what the sport.
While it’s hardly fair to credit the Castaic area as the primary source of elite athletes at Valencia, there’s also no question that diminishing the talent pool would have an adverse effect on the program down the road.
One example is Hart football. Since the end of open enrollment early last decade, the Indians haven’t won a CIF title or maintained the same consistent level of dominance.
Hart has still been competitive, and there are plenty of factors in play, but one of them is that the talent pool has been diminished with kids now attending Golden Valley and West Ranch.
The same thing could happen to Valencia, which has been the most dominant overall program in the area the past couple years. Some of the perennial league champions at Valencia include the softball, boys volleyball and boys and girls tennis teams.
“I don’t think we’re going to see long runs of dominance by any team,” says Greg Lee, the Coordinator of Diversity for the William S. Hart Union High School District. “We’re trying to balance those numbers out.”
That balance also occurred to Stiman, who points out that a Castaic high school could limit more than just Foothill League success.
It could impact how many CIF champions come from the valley.
“I think the bigger question is the level of play,” Stiman says. “Is it going to water us down too much? Is our level of play going to be watered down to where we can’t compete with other schools? That’s the question that comes to mind for me.”
Stiman says there is hope in that regard, and he references the Marmonte League, which expanded recently to include the football programs at Oaks Christian and St. Bonaventure. Even though the league is now 10 teams deep in football, nobody expects it to be anything but a powerhouse.
At the same time, those Ventura County schools are far more spread out than the Santa Clarita Valley schools, where schools are within 10 miles of one another.
Another question is just how quickly a Castaic high school can become competitive in sports.
“It won’t have much of an impact for quite a while because we’ll start with a ninth grade only,” says Pat Willett, spokeswoman for the Hart district. “It’s not going to have a full complement of grades until the 2017 school year.”
There are other concerns, too, according to Lee. The district has to figure out just how many kids are going to attend the Castaic high school, and then build the complex accordingly.
“You don’t want your school to be obsolete before it even opens,” Lee says.
There’s also a question of just how competitive a Castaic high school will be once it’s up and running.
Castaic’s youth sports programs have a strong reputation in the valley, and Valencia and West Ranch have benefited from their fair share of Castaic athletes.
That doesn’t mean, however, that a Castaic high school will automatically become one of the valley’s strongest programs.
“I don’t think it’s going to be that way,” Lee says. “The numbers at Castaic will be fairly small for quite awhile. I don’t think you’re going to see a large school enrollmentwise.”
Even if the Castaic high school quickly develops a strong athletic program, Stiman and Garcia feel that their schools have the coaches in place to keep the programs competitive.
“We do have a lot of good coaches,” Stiman says. “We might have more on-campus coaches than anybody. It creates a better atmosphere. I think you put all that together, yeah, it’ll help make the transition smoother.”
Maybe so, but the opening of a Castaic high school will likely level the local playing field more than ever.
The district is also interested in creating another high school after Castaic, one that would be situated for Stevenson Ranch and Newhall kids.
“The district’s going to continue to grow,” Lee says. “I think we’re going to see parity. It’ll be interesting when they build (the Stevenson Ranch/Newhall school). Castaic had better make their move while they can because they’ll be sharing talent pretty quickly, too.”
