City staffers may need the wisdom of Solomon and the patience of Job after being charged with making peace between irate neighbors and a church that wants to add a school.
The Santa Clarita Planning Commission voted 5-0 to have city staff come up with a compromise to appease both sides of the issue regarding the potential school in Happy Valley.
Staff has until Oct. 5 to come up with a compromise. That’s when a public hearing that began Tuesday night continues.
The Santa Clarita Seventh-day Adventist Church is asking the city to OK a parochial elementary school with as many as 218 students, including preschoolers.
The church has hosted a private, parochial school several times over the past 50 years, but always on a temporary basis.
So this latest request for another school, with more students than ever, irked the church’s neighbors. They complained of noisy and messy recesses and traffic jams on their residential streets.
Wayne Pursell, whose home sits on the school’s perimeter, said youngsters climb the schoolyard wall and hop onto his roof.
“I’m missing shingles,” he said. Further, Pursell contended that the students don’t pick up after themselves after lunch, and he’s found half-eaten sandwiches and pudding cups that were carried over by rats.
“We can’t win against a church,” he said. “But none of the (church) members live here on the street. This is the biggest investment I’ve made. I can’t afford to move.”
The noise is inescapable, said Pursell’s wife, Linda.
“We can’t get away from it,” she said. “The 25-foot setback didn’t work. The noise is all day. The neighbors have resigned themselves to it. We like children. We just want use of our home and our backyard.”
But church leaders said being good neighbors works both ways. Liz Caddow of Trinity Classical Academy, the school that rented the property from the church, said the neighbors’ complaints were “urban legends.”
“We were as respectful as we could be having kids on our yard playing at recess,” Caddow said. The school already had limited operating hours in hopes of appeasing the neighbors.
Congregation member Greg Hoenes said his church has accommodated neighbors with access to its property for moves, home-improvement projects and dog-walking without complaint.
“The school was there before any of the residents moved in,” Matthew Ferguson said.
The Planning Commission advised staff to develop a plan that involves fewer students, and maybe only younger children — not preteen ones.
“It’s unreasonable to constrain activities for those kids’ educations,” Commissioner Tim Burkhart said.
Commissioner Bill Kennedy said it wasn’t part of the original deal to have a permanent school there, but that a solution could be worked out.
