Soccer has become one of the most popular amateur sports in the country – and that popularity has led to a wealth of options for young players.
There’s the American Youth Soccer Organization. There are club teams. There’s the U.S. Soccer Development Academy.
There are so many options nowadays that school teams have been relegated in terms of importance.
But will these other teams — which require considerable time commitments — have a big impact on high school soccer in the future?
“I don’t think so,” says Valencia High head coach Tony Scalercio, who also coaches for the local club AC Milan. “Me personally, I played club soccer as a youth and I played high school soccer as a youth. They’re just different teams. It’s a different environment. I think once kids finish their club season, it’s almost a mini-vacation to play for your school and play with other players and enjoy yourselves.”
Most players start out playing AYSO soccer as children and can continue to do so until they’re 18 years of age. According to Mark Hovis, the area director for AYSO in the Santa Clarita Valley, the core program is geared toward kids who are 13 years old or younger.
Once the kids get older, he says, the numbers drop off for different reasons. Some kids try other sports once they get to high school. Others still play soccer but are looking at continuing the sport after high school.
That’s where club and academy come in.
High school soccer is generally more relaxed compared to club soccer, which is a step up in terms of competition, and academy soccer, which takes only the top players in a region.
“From a recruitment standpoint at the college level, coaches recruit their players from club soccer,” Scalercio says. “They’re not recruited from AYSO, not from high school in particular.”
The time commitments are different for each level, too. Whereas the high school season lasts three or four months in the winter, AYSO is available from July through November, right before the high school season begins.
The club and academy teams, meanwhile, are closer to year-round. Club typically breaks for the high school season, however, and academy doesn’t.
Just how much these other options will affect high school soccer remains to be seen.
“It’s case by case,” says Valencia High graduate and Cal State Bakersfield goalkeeper Eric Shannon. “Everyone’s different. I saw some people that thought they’d be on the lower level push themselves and get a starting spot. It is case by case, depending on what they want to do.”
Shannon was able to play at the club and academy level in addition to high school. Growing up, he played for the Los Angeles Football Club, which didn’t become an academy team until the U.S. Soccer Development Academy came to Southern California three years ago.
During his sophomore and junior years of high school, Shannon’s obligations to LAFC meant he couldn’t play high school soccer. He moved from LAFC to the L.A. Galaxy academy team his senior year, and the Galaxy allowed its players to play for their high schools, so he played for Valencia’s varsity team.
“It was fun,” Shannon says of his academy experience. “We got to travel. It’s a higher quality so it pushed me every day. You’re with your teammates four days a week, so it’s a fun experience and you get to grow as a player every day, so I liked it a lot.”
Other players from the Santa Clarita Valley have joined academy teams, including former Canyon players Matt Tellez and Robert Freise, former Golden Valley player Juan Sebastian De Rada and former Saugus player Erick Esquivel.
But it’s certainly not for everyone.
“It’s 100 percent a choice,” says Alberto Bru, head coach of the Real So Cal U15/16 academy team. “I’m not on campuses whispering, ‘Don’t play for Canyon High, don’t play for Hart High.’”
The club systems are somewhat similar to Europe, which takes players up through club systems at a very young age and educates them on the side.
Scalercio says that American soccer systems could be headed for trouble in that regard.
“That’s where we kind of miss out a little bit,” Scalercio says. “These youth clubs and teams may be selling a dream that you can stay in club and move on to the pros, but that’s not the way it works in America. Kids need to get an education first. Part of that is going to high school and then moving on to college, and then if you don’t play professionally, you have a college degree.”
That journey to college is something that the U.S. Soccer Development Academy has taken steps to ensure.
“The development academy has had three different ends,” Bru says. “One is yes, some of these players do represent the USA. Two, these players play professional soccer. But most of these kids will play college soccer.”
For the ones who aren’t as talented or committed, they can always play AYSO, which Scalercio says is a great organization in its own right.
But when players like Shannon come along, Scalercio has no problem recommending the club and academy system.
As long as they have the talent and commitment.
“There are some kids that decide even before high school that they have a blood line and they can go over to Europe and play,” Scalercio says. “You should follow that dream if you have that ability. For the run-of-the-mill club player, I think missing high school is a big mistake.”
